What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

The Raiders did it to Orford....

Tiger05

First Grade
Messages
9,871
Humphreys needs to grow a sack and take charge.
Deal Blair to England and split up the little partnership of Benji/Sheens that makes these f**ked up decisions.
Benji is as much to blame as Sheens, players shouldnt have this much influence over a team.

Great comment however there is absolutely no reality in it.

The rumor prior to Blair signing was that it wouldn't happen because Benji and Blair hated each other. That was obviously bullshit.
 

DanOz

Juniors
Messages
1,419
Agreed. He's one of the best defensive props I've seen in the last decade. Temper that against his lack of offensive skills and inability to get over the advantage line or create second phase play and you have what is a very standard first grade prop who would be a rotation prop for most teams. Just my thoughts on the guy.

I think its harsh to criticise him offensively after the workload he shouldered in defense. Just as Robbie was not his attacking best after 60+ tackles in origin, Gibbs could be forgiven for covering our weak defenders and not making as many meters as people would like.
 

madunit

Super Moderator
Staff member
Messages
62,358
Very good post DanOz. Gibbs is part of a massively better pack in attak and defense, allowing him to improve his attack.
 

tumblingdice

Juniors
Messages
213
I do think the Blair signing and some other recent ones (Reddy, Iosefa) shows that the talent spotting and recruitment skills are somewhat lacking at the Tigers.

I think i i know where those skills went to..maybe before they had a chance at WT. The Sharks of course.:crazy:

Sharks manager aims to construct a culture


BY BRAD FORREST
26 Jun, 2012 04:00 AM
BY ANY stretch, you?d have to consider the recruitment by Darren Mooney ? the silent ??partner?? of Cronulla Sharks head coach Shane Flanagan ? as one of the best in the NRL this season.Now, the trick is to add to a formula which has the Sharks running equal second: to transform a good Sharks side into a real powerhouse of the National Rugby League.
When former chief executive Richard Fisk followed disgruntled coach Ricky Stuart out the door in 2010, the financially struggling club chose not to replace Fisk directly. Instead, it was Mooney ? a former Wests Tigers welfare and Toyota Cup manager ? who was suddenly thrust alongside Flanagan as the Sharks? football club manager.
For 2011 the Sharks secured Kiwi international Jeremy Smith from the Dragons, promising Penrith utility Wade Graham, former Shark centre Colin Best from Souths and winger John Williams (Cowboys).
A poor start to 2011, with Cronulla losing nine of their first 13 games, convinced Mooney and Flanagan they needed more quality players for 2012, with experienced Peter Sharp also joining as assistant coach.
Utility Jeff Robson (Parramatta), props Ben Ross (Souths), Bryce Gibbs and Andrew Fifita (from Wests Tigers), were followed to Woolooware headquarters by former Shark hooker Isaac De Gois, forwards Mark Taufua (Knights) and Jon Green (Dragons) ? and then game-breaker, former Test half
Todd Carney.
Carney, along with captain Paul Gallen, has had a terrific influence on the Sharks? winning ways this season.
And despite an initial lukewarm reception from league critics, the rest of the Sharks new boys have shown the way.
Mooney is unquestionably a most reticent public speaker, preferring his coach to take up the heat of media scrutiny. But on this day, a week when the Sharks enjoyed a bye, Mooney said the club wants to build on its success.
??We only want players who really want be a part of this club,?? said Mooney. ??We only won seven games in both previous seasons [2010-11] so we?re pretty happy to have passed that for nine wins, just past the
halfway mark.??
There?s a popular theory that successful NRL clubs need five or six players with representative experience to evolve into powerhouses of the game.
Melbourne Storm have their three Queensland Origin and Test stars in Billy Slater, Cameron Smith and Cooper Cronk, with Test players Ryan Hoffman and Sika Manu, and others like Anthony Quinn and Dane Nielsen with recent Origin experience.
The Sharks, the first team to beat the Storm this season, have three ? Gallen, Carney and Smith ? with ??vacancies?? in the outside backs.
For 2013, Penrith recruit Michael Gordon (2010 Origin player) will give the Sharks four ? and there are some who see ??rep player?? in Wade Graham ? with the Sharks still on the lookout to bolster their ??elite?? ranks.
But Mooney, with five players off contract, cautions it might not happen overnight.
??We don?t want to just go out and pay ?overs? for someone to get him here,?? he said.
??We?re building a culture, and this is a really good place to come to, so we?re interested in those players wanting to become a Shark.??

http://www.theleader.com.au/news/lo...-construct-a-culture/2602343.aspx?storypage=0
 

Warrior@Heart

Juniors
Messages
829
I think he just doesn't care about the tigers, Adam Blair cared about the storm and played well, cares about the kiwis and played well. I think his heart just isn't there. I'd take him at the warriors for 300k any day.
 

Latest posts

Top