I actually agree with not picking May. He has been defensively suspect. Against us, he was awful. 2 or 3 of our players went straight through him for a clean line break up the middle. I think that would be the game that sealed his fate. Selectors might have been on the fence before that. I don't think, at least at this stage, May is an "origin player". I think he'd be exposed badly.
He is a quality, fit player who gets through a lot of work and has an offload in him. He is not yet at that top tier. He's been good this year with ball in hand, but in general it's been a bit overblown in terms of how good he's been.