The Slater try

[innsaneink]

My thoughts exactly.


Glad you brought that up

It only flaots forward if there is momentum - cutie was probing sideways when he threw that pass. UN less therewas a sudden tornado at Suncorp....FORWARD!!!

The Inglis miracle try was OK, too.

And Slater was onside.

Wow... resorting to fabrications now?
How sad is that.
Wallace, who passed to Hunt was going across sideways , Hunt was heading way more forward towards the tryline than sideways....but dont let the truth get in your way

 

[Rovelli]

The Inglis try should've been awarded probably, so it's a square-up.

Similarly, I thought the Kirk try was more conclusive than the Henderson try on Friday night.

 

[sass]

the fact no one jumped for the ball was an indication of brisbanes/bennets way of dealing with bombs. i dont think i've seen any other team in the past few years willing to let opposition teams get a jump at a ball in the air. even in attack broncos players rarely actually contest the ball

yeah that was shocking. they deserved that try to go through.

 

[Miller was a legend]

I think I can add something tangible to this tread about wether Slater was on or off side................................ Who gives a f**k! Game over no more tears, crying wont change anything.

 

[*Paul*]

Slater
http://members.iinet.net.au/~cromulent/2.jpg

 

[innsaneink]

Some idiot rang up zorba this morning claiming he was 2m offside...LOL

 

[camsmith]

/thread

 

[Crippler]

he was onside, but you cant use a parallel straight line to justify it like the above picture

 

[Stained_Class]

He looks onside to me in that pic without using the lines. Good enough for me.

 

[no name]

I loved how Vossy said on the Roast "he definitely scored" and didn't produce any evidence. I thought it was a try anyway but they could have at least showed some footage to back his claim.

 

[Butters]

Slaters a good 1m behind him.

 

[the kirwan kid]

I didn't see a great camera view on it, but the broncos deserved to concede that purely on the fact that everyone was looking to block Slater, but no one actually went up for the ball.

He was offside a bee's dick I reckon but I agree that he deserved the try for the broncos ordinary effort at stopping him.

 

[*Paul*]

Another view
http://ii.net/~cromulent/3.jpg

 

[_Johnsy]

On side, and deserved to be scored. The efforts at diffusing the bomb were attrocious.