strider
Post Whore
- Messages
- 78,827
- i think the last try that he disallowed for a forward pass was fair enough - it was forward - but what irks me is I have seen about 4 of them in the last few weeks which were all let go - yet we get pulled up
- the first manly try I believe was an obstruction - matai was running right off the decoy runners shoulder - o'dwyer didn't make a poor decision to take the wrong man (he did not run in to the decoy - he couls have taken either player), he just never had a clear shot at matai cos the decoy ran into the line just a second before matai ... this was the video refs stuff up tho
- why the hell did he need to go to the video for hayne's try - it was clearly just a great pickup from jarryd - not even a hint of a knock on .... the commentators claimed maybe he thought o'dwyer touched it??? (see the next point)
- why did clarke NOT go to the video on the first manly try after fui was sent? ... it clearly looked like williamson had knocked the ball at it went out wide .... oh no - good enough for clarky
- several times in the game manly had loiterers around their play the ball - and you could clearly hear clarke yelling at them to move ... but never a penalty - why bother yelling over and over - penalise them ffs
- the grapple tackle is ancient history nowdays - they've swallowed the whistle on it since about round 4 ... but no jeremy smith gets called for one while the rest of the game no one goes near th head - crap!
- caylo gets upended with an obvious dangerous throw early on and loses the ball in the process ... there was clearly a manly player with his hand between the legs lifting ... oh no - dipsh*t and his 2 blind mice were playing with themselves at the time
Lastly - one for caylo .... wtf was he on about when clarke called out BK and caylo and was telling BK to stop the penalties - and caylo chimes in "yeah come on" .... of course clark then proceeds to treat him like a 2yr old
- the first manly try I believe was an obstruction - matai was running right off the decoy runners shoulder - o'dwyer didn't make a poor decision to take the wrong man (he did not run in to the decoy - he couls have taken either player), he just never had a clear shot at matai cos the decoy ran into the line just a second before matai ... this was the video refs stuff up tho
- why the hell did he need to go to the video for hayne's try - it was clearly just a great pickup from jarryd - not even a hint of a knock on .... the commentators claimed maybe he thought o'dwyer touched it??? (see the next point)
- why did clarke NOT go to the video on the first manly try after fui was sent? ... it clearly looked like williamson had knocked the ball at it went out wide .... oh no - good enough for clarky
- several times in the game manly had loiterers around their play the ball - and you could clearly hear clarke yelling at them to move ... but never a penalty - why bother yelling over and over - penalise them ffs
- the grapple tackle is ancient history nowdays - they've swallowed the whistle on it since about round 4 ... but no jeremy smith gets called for one while the rest of the game no one goes near th head - crap!
- caylo gets upended with an obvious dangerous throw early on and loses the ball in the process ... there was clearly a manly player with his hand between the legs lifting ... oh no - dipsh*t and his 2 blind mice were playing with themselves at the time
Lastly - one for caylo .... wtf was he on about when clarke called out BK and caylo and was telling BK to stop the penalties - and caylo chimes in "yeah come on" .... of course clark then proceeds to treat him like a 2yr old
