Tim Smith > Jeff Robson

[COACH STERLING]

Couldn't stand the heat when it mattered. M I A

Like his team mates and chief master coach.

 

[parra pete]

Like his team mates and chief master coach.

Probably...

 

[ouchie]

And we could agrue that Robson went missing in the GF. But my point is you stated he was a one trick pony which if he was he would not have been able to lead the eels to two GF qualifier's and a minor premiership. Give the guy some credit.

Hayne led our team to the finals and gfinal, not robson.

 

[bartman]

And others led us to the 2005 GF and 2007 semis just as much as (if not more) than Smith, who by some still gets credited for it all in hindsight just because he had #7 on his back....

 

[parra pete]

:

Hayne led our team to the finals and gfinal, not robson.

:shock:

Moses led the Israelites out of the desert too...

 

[NorthShoreEel]

where does ben kusto sit?

Im just guessing, but....

 

[lingard]

Yes agree with what you are saying, my point was Timmy did it twice so he must be a little bit better then a "one trick pony". And he did it without a super 5/8 by his side.

And you can argue that, whatever Jeff Robson did in `09, he did without a super five-eight. I agree that the only thing Jeff Robson has proven so far is that he has had one very good season - but I still think he is under-rated.

 

[lingard]

:


:shock:

Moses led the Israelites out of the desert too...

Did he really, or was it the forwards who led the Israelites? I reckon Moses was over-rated.

 

[parra pete]

Flat out parting his hair, let alone the Red Sea.
There are a few people on here who remind me of Moses...Every time they open their mouths, the bull rushes...:lol: Sorry Bazal;