What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Todd Greenberg has got to go!

Are you happy with Greenberg's performance as CEO?

  • Yes

    Votes: 6 5.9%
  • No

    Votes: 86 85.1%
  • Undecided

    Votes: 9 8.9%

  • Total voters
    101

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
69,867
Can you post it? Behind paywall. Sounds a pretty weak argument, though if it is an NRL run event game they are after then its more likely the NRL wont see it as a money maker.

In UK it is traditional for a player to be given a testimonial year after 10 years service at a club, during the year a range of fundraising events happen. Having said that in this day and age of million $ contracts I'm really not sure players need this anymore.

Maybe if it was to raise money for charity it would be more appropriate and be a way of celebrating special players, at a club or NRL level.
 

The Rosco

Bench
Messages
2,909
Benji and Robbie might not have played their entire career at one club ( like JT, of course) . . . but importantly, they also were not the captain of the club that re-wrote history by having minor premierships and grand final wins stripped for cheating. Multi year, systematic, under the table cheating.
The captain of the club that put a massive black mark on the integrity of the game itself, that no "off season from hell" can come close to.
Of course you would reward him in the highest way possible.
 

Tiger5150

Bench
Messages
3,868
For what its worth I think the whole Testimonal game rort is rubbish, but Greenberg let that genie out of the bottle. Now all comes down to his whims again and apparently JT is more worthy and did more for the game than Benji.
 

Tiger5150

Bench
Messages
3,868
Can you post it? Behind paywall. Sounds a pretty weak argument, though if it is an NRL run event game they are after then its more likely the NRL wont see it as a money maker.

In UK it is traditional for a player to be given a testimonial year after 10 years service at a club, during the year a range of fundraising events happen. Having said that in this day and age of million $ contracts I'm really not sure players need this anymore.

Maybe if it was to raise money for charity it would be more appropriate and be a way of celebrating special players, at a club or NRL level.

C&P



Benji Marshall has done more for rugby league than most players in the game’s history, let alone this generation.
Throughout his illustrious career, Marshall has been one of the game’s biggest drawcards — and the amount of fans he has brought to the sport just to watch his magic would have made millions upon millions in revenue in Australia and New Zealand.
Throughout it all, Benji never embarrassed himself on or off the field, and was pretty much the instigator of a Kiwi revolution. But apparently that still does not qualify Benji for an end-of-season testimonial.
And under the NRL’s ridiculous guidelines, Robbie Farah won’t be getting one, either.
In their glorious wisdom, the NRL has told the two Tigers champions that they don’t meet the same criteria that was afforded to Cameron Smith, Johnathan Thurston and, somewhat reluctantly, John Sutton.
Talk about rules for some and rules for others. Get this. The reason is because Marshall and Farah have not played their entire careers at one club.
We all know they were forced out back when the Tigers were going through some difficult years.
But Benji has still played 225 NRL games for the Tigers (292 all up) and meets every other criteria, while Farah has 263 Tigers games (289 all up) and meets all other guidelines.
The NRL is forgetting JT played the early part of his career at Canterbury. And while Thurston and Smith were on $1 million contracts, this year Marshall is playing for $170,000 and Farah is on $190,000, not much above minimum NRL wage.
The NRL will say it has been given the green light to have a testimonial dinner but what about the fans who might also want to celebrate what should be such a wonderful occasion? It is rubbish and let’s hope it is not too late to overturn.

Cut & paste credit to @theunknown in the Tigers forum
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
69,867
Does anyone rate this Greenberg?
He actually makes the blokes before him seem honest.

The bar is low. Very low.
98-99 Neil Whitaker - Closed down Adelaide and Gold Coast, poorly thought out merger and reduction strategy.
00-02 David Moffett - Readmitted Souths, Warriors financially collapsed, pretty much gave away naming rights to Telstra
02-11 Gallop - the less said the better
12-15 Smith - Tried his best to run the joint like a business and bring RL into 21st century, failed badly and got knifed in back over daring to take on Murdoch. Did a good job handling the Sharks druggie scandal, lacked the RL nous to deal with the factions
16- Greenberg commences his reign with the famous line "I wouldn't describe myself as a visionary" and has done his best to live up to it. Mr knee jerk would be a good nickname
 

no name

Referee
Messages
20,123
And Cam $mith wouldn’t have played his whole career at Melbourne if he didn’t sign multiple contracts.

As someone said earlier, the whole idea of a testimonial these days is just a salary cap scam, but once you let two of the highest paid players in on the rort, you open yourself up for a hiding to nothing.
 

AnonymousLurker

Juniors
Messages
1,922
I came on here To vent as the two tigers players are entitled to the rort especially with smith still continuing to play despite having a testimonial.. wtf if that is not a cap rort I don't know what is

However you have all summed it well .
 

langpark

First Grade
Messages
5,867
Benji, the guy that tried to defect to union and only returned because was a massive failure there.

How about that as a headline? No, they prefer instead to try and create an uproar by saying 'done more for league than anyone' and all sorts of other nonsense. And I also love how we are supposed to pity them for being (only) on $200k contracts!!
 

The unknown

Juniors
Messages
2,495
Benji, the guy that tried to defect to union and only returned because was a massive failure there.

How about that as a headline? No, they prefer instead to try and create an uproar by saying 'done more for league than anyone' and all sorts of other nonsense. And I also love how we are supposed to pity them for being (only) on $200k contracts!!

Benji, the guy who was idolized by 100s of thousands of kids playing league.

Does anyone actually idolize Cameron Smith? I don't see kids trying to backchat referees or signing multiple contracts

Also the one club player thing is hilarious, like mentioned in the article as JT started his career at Dogs.
 

AnonymousLurker

Juniors
Messages
1,922
Benji, the guy that tried to defect to union and only returned because was a massive failure there.

How about that as a headline? No, they prefer instead to try and create an uproar by saying 'done more for league than anyone' and all sorts of other nonsense. And I also love how we are supposed to pity them for being (only) on $200k contracts!!

The uproar is well deserved tho , if the whole process was not a rort I don't know what is . He is not a clean skin and has played for another nrl club.

Not one but 2 instances of being arrested by police
https://www.couriermail.com.au/news...6a8f4a0cc?sv=1292140245bef2e8eb1de88d1069470d

Cam smith signing multiple contracts with storm cap saga and on top the testimonial has come and gone and he is still playing 2 years later and apparently playing next year .
 

Tiger5150

Bench
Messages
3,868
Benji, the guy that tried to defect to union and only returned because was a massive failure there.

How about that as a headline? No, they prefer instead to try and create an uproar by saying 'done more for league than anyone' and all sorts of other nonsense. And I also love how we are supposed to pity them for being (only) on $200k contracts!!

Im not actually recommending that they get a testimonial.

My point is simply the hypocricy of Greenburg and the continual inconsistencies and pumping up the powerful,
 

Chimp

Bench
Messages
2,871
Hypocrocy is the way of the NRL world.

Testimonials for some, denied for others...

Retirement salary cap exemption for some, not for others...

Stood down based on allegations for some, welcomed back into the game following serious criminal convictions for others... oh and character references for others too...

Seriously, how can he really use 'the impact on the brand' as evidence for standing down JDB (who is innocent until proven guilty), but welcome back the likes of Lodge, Tetavano and others. And then throw in the GI character reference - in my opinion these examples alone make his position untenable.

But it's not about consistency he says, it's about fairness..... His views on fairness are obviously different to mine and those of natural justice.
 

AJB1102

First Grade
Messages
6,339
Seriously, how can he really use 'the impact on the brand' as evidence for standing down JDB (who is innocent until proven guilty), but welcome back the likes of Lodge

He then uses 500 emails from unhappy fans to backup standing JDB down and the feelings of his daughter's touch footy side.

He didn't take fan opinion into the Lodge decision, shit not even Broncos fans wanted the merkin. Lodge was booed every time he touched the ball even at Suncorp for f**ks sake. Can only assume the girl's touch side was okay with Lodge's little night out in NY.
 

Latest posts

Top