Un-signable players

[Bib]

Who in their right mind would offer a contract to the following players

1. Brett Finch
2. Chris Walker
3. Owen Craige
4. John Hoppoate

These guys have some of the worst attitudes in the NRL

 

[MONY]

chris walker would be a good signing for Brisbane... Bennett would whip him into shape and imo he could take botts position.

Hunt
Tate
Berrigan
Hodges
Walker
Lockyer
Seymour

That would be quite unstoppable.

 

[jimmy_pop]

john hoppa would go to the roosters - he has the same attitude as the club itself!

 

[JoeysWheelchair05]

chris walker would be a good signing for Brisbane... Bennett would whip him into shape and imo he could take botts position.

Hunt
Tate
Berrigan
Hodges
Walker
Lockyer
Seymour

That would be quite unstoppable.

Nah, we don't want Walker, definitely not. Bott is good enough until the end of the Rugby Union world cup in 2007....

 

[ozzie]

john hoppa would go to the roosters - he has the same attitude as the club itself!

more like Brisbane - the most arrogant club in the comp

 

[Jackal Dog]

Finch to either to the bunnies or warriors
Walker to the Reds
Craige to centerlink
Hoppa to sh*t shield NSWRU

 

[aussies1st]

2 of the 4 players listed from the Roosters. What is up with their club.

 

[Mr Saab]

also missed out these players :

Dane Carlaw.
Scott Minto.

 

[bluesbreaker]

What the hell happened to Carlaw? He used to be awesome.

 

[aussies1st]

He obviously went crap!

 

[Mr Saab]

No idea...but for a player of his size and "potential" he should be up with Tallis.
At the moment, and for the last 3 yrs he has been down there with Tyran Smith

 

[jed]

No idea...but for a player of his size and "potential" he should be up with Tallis.
At the moment, and for the last 3 yrs he has been down there with Tyran Smith

Ouch!!!

 

[The Colonel]

What the hell happened to Carlaw? He used to be awesome.

.

A small overstatement. A particularly capable player if he uses his size advantage but not quite awesome. Could possibly find some form with a move to another club......

 

[Bring back John Fifita]

What the hell happened to Carlaw? He used to be awesome.

When I heard Dish-head Dowlings quote on Carlaw I pissed myself laughing.

Quote "Dane Carlaw Looks like Tarzan & plays like Jane"

Back on topic - add Willie Manu to the list. I used to rate him highly, and when the Dragons signed him I thought he would be a great asset, hits hard and runs hard. Or at least he used to - went off the rails and now in on the scrapheap well before his time.

 

[bluesbreaker]

.

A small overstatement. A particularly capable player if he uses his size advantage but not quite awesome. Could possibly find some form with a move to another club......

He used to be a monster, one of the best forwards in the comp. Now he's soft, bit of Josh Perryitis I suppose.

 

[hybrid_tiger]

Todd Carney.

 

[Mr Saab]

He used to be a monster, one of the best forwards in the comp. Now he's soft, bit of Josh Perryitis I suppose.

monster? does Jane Carlaw have a brother called Tarzan?
Carlaw has done one thing in his career and thats beat Moodie and Hodgson to score a try in origin 3 2002.

 

[bluesbreaker]

monster? does Jane Carlaw have a brother called Tarzan?
Carlaw has done one thing in his career and thats beat Moodie and Hodgson to score a try in origin 3 2002.

I remember watching him play for Brisbane and thinking where the hell the factory is that these guys are coming from. Perhaps I was wrong, you're the Brisbane expert.

 

[Mr Saab]

no expert, but i have seen enough of him now to know he is missing "something"

 

[The Colonel]

He used to be a monster, one of the best forwards in the comp. Now he's soft, bit of Josh Perryitis I suppose.

Injuries can do weird things to players....... he has never really been a monster though unless you mean in the Mike Wasowski mould rather than a James P. Sullivan......