Wally Lewis vs Andrew Johns

[bluesbreaker]

True

I guess i'll leave the joey brigade to their usual spank the monkeyathon

I noticed you didn't answer me. I ask again, please provide an example of Johns limping around when his team is losing (it happens nearly every time apparently, so it shouldn't be hard).

... Or you could just admit that you're hatred of Johns makes you lie through your teeth.

 

[strewth_mate]

From what iv seen and herd, i think they are both good players.

:lol: Can't argue with that, sums it up for me

 

[bluesbreaker]

*bump*

Still no answer hey Kiwi? That's ok, I guess we all know you're talking bullsh*t. For some consistency, how about you put this lie in your signature as well?

 

[DJ1]

I absolutely hated him with a passion, but I would have to say Wally Lewis by a long way!

 

[gregstar]

tired.


after round 12.

 

[Brutus]

Wally is the king

End of story.

 

[Palms]

Both the best players in their respective positions who have both had stellar careers. I think the bagging of Johns is very unfair. Look at the team he has been carrying for some time now, that alone would have to take its toll. Not to mention the weight of a town on his shoulders (lets not forget the team Wally had uner his belt with a QUALITY half in Langer and a forward pack to boot!)

All in all, unfair on both players to have one stand out as the best.

 

[Mr Saab]

What crap does Johns cop and why are you underestimating the Knights pack over the past 10 yrs?
Names that come to mind are that played with Johns over the yrs...

Harragon
Simpson
BK
Parsons
Glanville
Muir
Butterfield

Those were not exactly marshmellows.

 

[Palms]

Im talking about the crap from these forums, he cops plenty!

Harrigon, Butterfield, Glanville all pre 2000 with Muir not far after. I did not say they had a poor forward pack but have always been lackiong somewhat in the depth department for the last few years and in comparison to the Brisbane forward pack in relationship to playing careers, I would say Brisbane had alot more depth and skill?

 

[Foz]

I'd take Wally for rep games and Johns for club games.
Is that a draw?

 

[Mr Saab]

Im talking about the crap from these forums, he cops plenty!

Harrigon, Butterfield, Glanville all pre 2000 with Muir not far after. I did not say they had a poor forward pack but have always been lackiong somewhat in the depth department for the last few years and in comparison to the Brisbane forward pack in relationship to playing careers, I would say Brisbane had alot more depth and skill?

He doesnt cop crap for his playing ability. He cops crap for his sometimes childish actions.
Are you referring to depth and skill in the forwards in Wallys days at the broncos? Brisbane didnt make the semis in 1988, lost playoff for 5th in 1989 (sharks) and got to the prelim final of 1990.

 

[The Preacher]

I haven't known things quite as bad as tonight.

Lewis played too many years ago to get anything near balanced =this poll is stupid and only people who have seen both fully should vote/comment which wont happend thus ridiculous thread.

Well then, you're only a little lad eh marky, so shut the f**k up and watch the opinions of those that have seen both, kiddy.

I rated Lewis the third best I had seen, behind Chang and Bozo, but this bucket bum Novacastrian is the best I've ever seen, and unless some freak comes along in the next 23yrs then my 3 score and 10 will be up and it'll be permenant shuteye time, so he'll still be the best.

 

[Palms]

Gavin ALLEN Sam BACKO Alan CANN Greg DOWLING Andrew GEE Mark HOHN Peter JACKSON Terry MATTERSON Gene MILES John PLATH Kerrod WALTERS all played in those 3 years you were talking about.

 

[bluey]

Seen wally at his peak and johns at his peak.

JOHNS for me better all round kicking game, both good defenders ,both good vision.

 

[Mr Saab]

Gavin ALLEN Sam BACKO Alan CANN Greg DOWLING Andrew GEE Mark HOHN Peter JACKSON Terry MATTERSON Gene MILES John PLATH Kerrod WALTERS all played in those 3 years you were talking about.

Not going to go thru them one by one, but the majority were either at the end of their careers, or were not THAT great.
Peter Jackson was not a forward
Plath was a benchy throughout his entire career.

 

[Mal Meninga]

From what iv seen and herd, i think they are both good players.

:lol: :lol: :lol:
Classic cWo.