What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Warriors Game Thread

Pika

Bench
Messages
3,641
Gidley was lucky not to get 10.

We were 5-0 down in penalties for the second half.

I dont care about conceding, but show me a team that is perfect, on side, square at marker etc etc, for an entire half???

Give me a break.
 

Big Tim

First Grade
Messages
6,500
Oh the early tackle that even the biased Pearce agreed with?

You can not justify gidley not going to the bin. It was a blatant professional foul.

If the early tackle against Faas was a penalty, then so was the big hit on Hilder..... he caught the ball at the exact moment he was hit. Faas made a reach before the ball got there, but contact was, at worst, simaltaneous.

The deal is mate, you think you were done hard by, but bad kicking won us the game. Kemp missed a simple goal, Kurt missed at least 3. If he had kicked 2 of those the game would have been over mid way through the second.
 

Apey

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
28,329
Gidley was lucky not to get 10.

We were 5-0 down in penalties for the second half.

I dont care about conceding, but show me a team that is perfect, on side, square at marker etc etc, for an entire half???

Give me a break.

Now now. The refs were on our side apparently.

I am pretty happy with all the tries. I originally thought McKinnon was offside, I watched it a few times however and would say he's in line at best; try nonetheless.

The only try I wouldn't have given, or have a slight bit of confusion over (omgogmgogm bias) was I think the Warriors 3rd one. Where he had the ball on the ground before it but no conclusive evidence that he had it on the ground after the line? I suppose that's what benefit of the doubt is, but I still believe he was held up.

Oh well according to the game thread it seems you only have bias and wrong opinions if you're a knights fan. I am just happy we got the win. The whiners can cry all day about the refs being on our side (for the record, I think Gidley should have been put in the bin too) and it won't change the fact we got the two points. ;-)
 
Messages
16,034
Really really sh*t game I thought.

Knights completion rate would have to be up there for the worst, not only this season but of all time!

Gidley shouldn't be goal kicker any more too, it's costing us, we could have been up 30-12, and that would have most likely turned into 40-12 but instead the Warriors were still in it and almost stole a win, and probably should have.

Dureau was a bit of a dud, I don't think there is any use for him any more unless Rogers or Mullen get injured.

What was the crowd any way? looked to be about 18-19k to me?

And now im starting to get concerned with our fitness, what is with us? We need to start stopping offloads.

Paterson was shocking I thought, fair enough 1st game back, but he hasn't been good in any game.

And finally, Dragons are next. This will be a good test, although I think we're in for a touch up, Dragons 30 - 10.

Couldnt have put it better sick of seeing us win ugly against 2nd string injury riddled teams.

Will be interesting to see us against the dragons, could be a long day unless we vastly improve.
 

Serc

First Grade
Messages
6,902
I also thought I'd add that I was impressed with De Gois on Sunday...best game for us so far and pretty faultless (aside from that knock on in our first set :lol:)
 
Top