Firey_Dragon
Coach
- Messages
- 12,099
Has nothing to do with whether or not they make the playoffs. It's how the QB performs in the playoffs, we haven't seen him under that sort of pressure, plenty of players look great during the regular season only to struggle in the playoffs where it steps up another level. That's where great QB's shine.I think making the playoffs is too simplistic of a metric to decide if a QB is top 10 or if a team team has truly turned a corner...
I mean Brian Hoyer made the playoffs last season... yet I don't think anyone on planet earth other than Mrs Hoyer would say he's a better QB than Carr.
The team will just have to make the playoffs I guess...
For the record I'd have Brady, Rodgers, Brees, Roethlisburger, Luck, Wilson, Newton, Dalton, Ryan, Rivers all ahead of him with Carr falling somewhere in the next group of 5-8 with the likes of Winston, Manning, Stafford, Wentz (even Bradford this season)etc.
Last edited: