What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

What would be the biggest upset in week 1?

What would be the biggest upset in week 1?

  • England beat Australia

    Votes: 9 20.0%
  • Samoa beat NZ

    Votes: 7 15.6%
  • Wales beat PNG

    Votes: 2 4.4%
  • USA beat Fiji

    Votes: 15 33.3%
  • Scotland beat Tonga

    Votes: 9 20.0%
  • Lebanon beat France

    Votes: 5 11.1%
  • Ireland beat Italy

    Votes: 3 6.7%

  • Total voters
    45

titoelcolombiano

First Grade
Messages
6,620
"We can't play more games because we currently don't play many games" isn't really a great excuse though is it

Agree mate - if the four nations doesn't return (which it looks like it probably won't) we plenty of room in the calendar for internationals, both one-off and series. We continue to have a mid-season rep window where England must play New Zealand alongside the Pacific Tests. Then post-season we must have annual Pacific, Euro and Atlantic Cups.

The big three then can play 6 tests post season: England can tour every second year and play Australia twice and NZ twice and the winner of the Pacific Cup then return to Europe to play the Euro Cup champions. During an English tour Aus & NZ will play England twice each, each other twice and both play the Pac cup champions.

Every other year the Kiwis and Kangaroos can play a warm up test against an island nation each, play each other twice then go north each play England twice each and then both play the Euro Cup champions. During these years England will play a warm up test against the previous years Euro Cup champions, Aus & NZ twice each and play the new reigning Euro Cup champs.

This gives the same benefits that the Four Nations gave but better; it gives access to the teir two nations to earn the right to play with the big boys hence giving the Euro and Pac cups more meaning (on top of the already significant meaning of a major trophy) but both Euro and Pac champions will get to do so pretty much annually, not every second year when the 4N gets played in their hemisphere.

7 tests a year for England and New Zealand
6 tests a year for Australia plus State of Origin
Minimum 3 tests a year for the best Pacific and Euro nations with the winners getting bonuses of between 1 and 3 matches with the big 3

If Australia choose to sit-out certain years, so be it, but the schedule rolls on without them and England and NZ play a 3 test series instead.
 

Rory

Juniors
Messages
188
Fairly dumb thread imo. Because lebanon v france, ireland v italy, nz vs samoa, wales vs png arnt upsets. Samoa vs NZ i can understand being an upset, because its bloody NZ, but still, these teams are fairly evenly matched, and weve never seen them play before, therefore you cannot claim there upsets.
 

Golden point

Juniors
Messages
456
Fairly dumb thread imo. Because lebanon v france, ireland v italy, nz vs samoa, wales vs png arnt upsets. Samoa vs NZ i can understand being an upset, because its bloody NZ, but still, these teams are fairly evenly matched, and weve never seen them play before, therefore you cannot claim there upsets.
" fairly dumb thread"
Then go's on to express his opinion....
Hmmm
Anyway..so there's no favorites?
Interesting.
So every minute I look at the horses i see that there is a favorite... but how could that be when they have never raced each other?
I'm just speculating but if I went to place a bet on any of these games there will probably be a favourite.
Maybe if you don't like someone's thread then just move on.
 

Rory

Juniors
Messages
188
" fairly dumb thread"
Then go's on to express his opinion....
Hmmm
Anyway..so there's no favorites?
Interesting.
So every minute I look at the horses i see that there is a favorite... but how could that be when they have never raced each other?
I'm just speculating but if I went to place a bet on any of these games there will probably be a favourite.
Maybe if you don't like someone's thread then just move on.

my right to express my opinion, if i wrote a dumb thread or dumb comment, fair game. the point of a forum is for everyone to express there ideas and views, and there will be disagreements, so yeah, smd
 

adamkungl

Immortal
Messages
42,971
Im thinking Ireland v Italy will be one of the closer ones - Tedesco the only stand out, rest of the sides fairly well matched
 

adamkungl

Immortal
Messages
42,971
Vaughan and Nathan Brown were two of the absolute best forwards in the NRL this year. The gap is a bit bigger than that

It's a big drop from those 2 though, and Amor and McCarthy-Scarsbrook are no slouches, they'll hold their own.
Ireland have the advantage at 9 with one of the top SL hookers in McIllorum lining up against a QLD Cup player.

The halves are tough to get a read on - Campese too old and Johns too young for Italy, while Ireland have Pewharaingi and Finn, neither are world beaters.

2-5s we have nobodies galore on both sides.

I'll stick with my prediction that the difference is Tedesco.
 

Rhino_NQ

Immortal
Messages
33,050
i can see the poms, samoans and yanks going down swinging but if scotland get within 30 points of tonga ill be surprised so i go with the scots as the biggest if it happens
 

Latest posts

Top