Who do we want re-signed?

[Rich102]

These are the guys off-contract at the end of the year.
Who do you want re-signed?
Reply with your list and I will tally them up in a couple of weeks.

Jacob Lillyman 2017
Ryan Hoffman 2017
Matt Allwood 2017
Bodene Thompson 2017
Ben Matulino 2017
Blake Ayshford 2017
Ligi Sao 2017
Toafofoa Sipley 2017
Albert Vete 2017
Nathaniel Roache 2017
Erin Clark 2017
Ofahiki Ogden 2017
Patrick Sipley 2017
Charlie Gubb 2017
Charnaze Nicole-Klokstad 2017
Ata Hingano 2017
Mason Lino 2017
Jordan Pinnock 2017
Matthew Sauni 2017
Tevin Arona 2017
Sam Cook 2017
Chris Satae 2017

 

[Rich102]

Must sign:
Blake Ayshford 2017
Toafofoa Sipley 2017
Patrick Sipley 2017
Charnaze Nicole-Klokstad 2017
Ata Hingano 2017
Mason Lino 2017
Sam Cook 2017
Chris Satae 2017

At the right price:
Jacob Lillyman 2017
Ligi Sao 2017
Albert Vete 2017
Nathaniel Roache 2017
Erin Clark 2017
Ofahiki Ogden 2017


I haven't seen enough of these to form an opinion:
Jordan Pinnock 2017
Matthew Sauni 2017
Tevin Arona 2017

 

[Blair]

Tof & Pat Sip, Ata, Satae, Lino, Ayshford, Charnze, Vete, Bull, Allwood, Sao.

I don't some of the younger players.

 

[Cold Roses]

Re Sign:

Blake Ayshford 2017
Ligi Sao 2017
Toafofoa Sipley 2017
Ofahiki Ogden 2017
Patrick Sipley 2017
Charnaze Nicole-Klokstad 2017
Ata Hingano 2017
Mason Lino 2017
Chris Satae 2017

Re sign but last chance to prove himself:

Albert Vete 2017

Don't Re Sign:
Seeing as we already have Tevaga, we don't need to keep this many Hooker/Utilities. I'll say no, because i'd assume Kearney will keep Tevaga and Roache.

Nathaniel Roache 2017
Erin Clark 2017
Sam Cook 2017

Depth players
Leave them to develop in the lower grades

Jordan Pinnock 2017
Matthew Sauni 2017
Tevin Arona 2017

Desperately Unlucky

Jacob Lillyman.
Possibly re sign as depth, but I honestly believe it's time to move on. Matulino is already going anyway, and it's time we moved on. It's a hard call, but it's a no from me.

 

[Rich102]

"Wenty kick off as we recieve but after tackle 3 Vete knocks on in the contact so Wenty have a full set in our 30 but cant get past our defence and they kick dead giving us a 7 tackle set. " This was from R&S's report.

Small mistakes, but costly. Every time I watch Vete there is a mistake coming up.

 

[Fufu Andronez]

Jacob Lillyman 2017
Blake Ayshford 2017
Ligi Sao 2017
Toafofoa Sipley 2017
Albert Vete 2017
Nathaniel Roache 2017
Patrick Sipley 2017
Charnaze Nicole-Klokstad 2017
Ata Hingano 2017
Mason Lino 2017
Jordan Pinnock 2017
Chris Satae 2017

 

[ozbash]

Blake Ayshford 2017
Ligi Sao 2017
Toafofoa Sipley
Erin Clark 2017
Ofahiki Ogden 2017
Patrick Sipley 2017
Charnaze Nicole-Klokstad 2017
Ata Hingano 2017
Mason Lino 2017
Jordan Pinnock 2017
Sam Cook 2017

 

[jaseg]

Must sign:
Blake Ayshford 2017
Toafofoa Sipley 2017
Patrick Sipley 2017
Charnaze Nicole-Klokstad 2017
Ata Hingano 2017
Mason Lino 2017
Sam Cook 2017
Chris Satae 2017

At the right price:
Jacob Lillyman 2017
Ligi Sao 2017
Albert Vete 2017
Nathaniel Roache 2017
Erin Clark 2017
Ofahiki Ogden 2017


I haven't seen enough of these to form an opinion:
Jordan Pinnock 2017
Matthew Sauni 2017
Tevin Arona 2017

This. (Well, I've seen Pinnock and Arona... both at the right price... which is the bare minimum 2nd tier depending on who goes/stays/arrives.. and maybe not even that RE Pinnock - Arona is an injured bench hooker in NSW cup, Pinnock is an average middle forward about to age out of NYC)

Although I'd maybe bump Roache into "must sign". I think he is (at just 21 years of age) one of the top 5 hookers not playing in the NRL at the moment (not looking at SL) - and I don't trust Issac Luke.

 

[Benek]

With big Ben gone next year I think we have to give Lillyman a 1 year extension. Guys like Lisone and Vete haven't proven themselves reliable first graders yet. Guys like the Sipleys haven't even got a crack yet. We will need at least one experienced cool head in the pack so unless we are recruiting an experienced prop before next season lets hang on to Bull.

 

[ZEROMISSTACKLES]

Jacob Lillyman 2017
Ryan Hoffman 2017
Matt Allwood 2017
Bodene Thompson 2017
Ben Matulino 2017
Blake Ayshford 2017
Toafofoa Sipley 2017
Albert Vete 2017
Nathaniel Roache 2017
Erin Clark 2017
Ofahiki Ogden 2017*
Patrick Sipley 2017*
Charnaze Nicole-Klokstad 2017
Ata Hingano 2017
Mason Lino 2017
Jordan Pinnock 2017*
Matthew Sauni 2017*
Tevin Arona 2017*
Sam Cook 2017
Chris Satae 2017*

*= because I havent seen them play and I dont think they've played 1st grade.

 

[One Warrior]

Re Sign

Nicole Klokstad
Sipley x 2
Satae
Roache
Hingano
Lino
Ayshford
Sao
Ogden

If we can't sign an experienced prop, resign Lillyman for a further year for his experience and try again next year for an experienced prop. Vete I believe we have an option on for next year, take up that option
for his last chance.

 

[RHYTHM AND STEALTH]

Apparanty we have offered Bodene a new contract but wants to test his market value.

His market value is poos at the moment

 

[KeepingTheFaith]

Warriors like to announce low level signings in bunches. Some of these guys are already signed.

Keen to see who we bring in before worrying about who we re-sign but I think CNK, Roache, Satae, Hingano and Sipley boys are must keeps.

 

[Penrose Warrior]

Apparanty we have offered Bodene a new contract but wants to test his market value.

His market value is poos at the moment

Yeah, great idea. I mean he's playing f**king awfully around contract negotiation time, which is generally when inconsistent middle of the road players like him traditionally do their best work. Can't wait to see him perform worse once his future is secure!

 

[Penrose Warrior]

I'm really interested on the Hingano one. I always thought he was a must-keep, but now I'm not so sure. Kearney would've been getting a good look at him in NSW Cup, his character, how he trains...if he's not re-signed, I'd suggest it's nothing to do with Foran and lack of opportunities but how Ata has carried himself.

And on Jake, he's a must-keep for me if we're not replacing him with experience from the market. I can't see how you can go into 2018 with Lisone, Vete, Gavet, Pulu (presuming he's signed as a front rower) and the NSW Cup boys.

 

[TheDMC]

Yeah we would be nuts to not re-sign Lillyman. He is the type of consistent, hard, no-frills forward that is a must have (and have some more dynamic players around).

 

[Penrose_11]

Re-sign
Jacob Lillyman 2017
Blake Ayshford 2017
Ligi Sao 2017
Toafofoa Sipley 2017
Albert Vete 2017
Ofahiki Ogden 2017
Patrick Sipley 2017
Charnaze Nicole-Klokstad 2017
Ata Hingano 2017
Mason Lino 2017

No
Ryan Hoffman 2017
Matt Allwood 2017
Bodene Thompson 2017
Ben Matulino 2017
Charlie Gubb 2017

Unsure
Nathaniel Roache 2017
Erin Clark 2017
Jordan Pinnock 2017
Matthew Sauni 2017
Tevin Arona 2017
Sam Cook 2017
Chris Satae 2017

 

[RHYTHM AND STEALTH]

Re-sign
Jacob Lillyman 2017
Blake Ayshford 2017
Ligi Sao 2017
Toafofoa Sipley 2017
Albert Vete 2017
Ofahiki Ogden 2017
Patrick Sipley 2017
Charnaze Nicole-Klokstad 2017
Ata Hingano 2017
Mason Lino 2017

No
Ryan Hoffman 2017
Matt Allwood 2017
Bodene Thompson 2017
Ben Matulino 2017
Charlie Gubb 2017

Unsure
Nathaniel Roache 2017
Erin Clark 2017
Jordan Pinnock 2017
Matthew Sauni 2017
Tevin Arona 2017
Sam Cook 2017
Chris Satae 2017

Of the unsures Sam Cook and Satae go good. Pinnock was supoosed to be the next rising start wasnt he