Who is the better player, Slater or Inglis?

[diddi kong]

Inglis is better than Slater, Slater is better than Hayne.

 

[badav]

Slater is very quick, puts in whole-heartedly, but is prone to error.
Inglis is quicker, and seems to be unbeatable when the need arises.

But there are very good arguments that he's not even the best fullback in the game. He can go missing when the heat is turned up defensively.

Look at last nights game - Slater was rubbish behind a badly beaten pack, but Inglis shone like a star.

Be interesting to see what sort of player Slater is when he has $2million less in talent around him...

He would still be a class player. One of his assets is how dangerous he is in broken play situations, and those arise irrespective of how far your pack is pushing forwards.