Who is the least deserving Immortal?

[Knuckle-dragger]

The Immortals

Clive Churchill (inducted in 1981 - 5 premierships)
Bob Fulton (1981 - 3)
Reg Gasnier (1981-7)
Johnny Raper (1981 - 8)
Graeme Langlands (1999 - 4)
Wally Lewis (1999 - 3)
Arthur Beetson (2003 - 3)
Andrew Johns (2012 - 2)
Dave Brown (2018 - 4)
Dally Messenger (2018 - 3)
Frank Burge (2018 - 0)
Norm Provan (2018 - 10)
Mal Meninga (2018 - 5)

In my opinion the least deserving Immortal is Mal Meninga.

 

[Brutus]

Mark line-speed Gasnier's uncle

 

[Canard]

Nice troll

 

[ReddFelon]

I mean it is Meninga, he didn't really do anything that remarkable.

 

[Pommy]

Has anyone got as much off field baggage as johns?

 

[Lemon Squash]

The ones that are dead

 

[Fangs]

Mal.

 

[jargan83]

What has Rugby League ever given me

 

[Rhino_NQ]

Is the "mal only ever ran at skinny wingers" still a thing?

 

[AlwaysGreen]

The Immortals

Clive Churchill (inducted in 1981 - 5 premierships)
Bob Fulton (1981 - 3)
Reg Gasnier (1981-7)
Johnny Raper (1981 - 8)
Graeme Langlands (1999 - 4)
Wally Lewis (1999 - 3)
Arthur Beetson (2003 - 3)
Andrew Johns (2012 - 2)
Dave Brown (2018 - 4)
Dally Messenger (2018 - 3)
Frank Burge (2018 - 0)
Norm Provan (2018 - 10)
Mal Meninga (2018 - 5)

In my opinion the least deserving Immortal is Mal Meninga.

And who the f**k are you again?

 

[veggiepatch1959]

The ones that are dead

Especially the last one that died.

 

[veggiepatch1959]

The least deserving are.....




....the four that I never saw play live.

 

[veggiepatch1959]

I mean it is Meninga, he didn't really do anything that remarkable.

Only in politics.

 

[Danish]

Wally Lewis would be my pick.

How many other immortals had their clubs win back to back premierships after kicking their ass to the curb?

 

[Knuckle-dragger]

Wally Lewis would be my pick.

How many other immortals had their clubs win back to back premierships after kicking their ass to the curb?

Yes in my original post I was going to say it's a coin toss between Wally and Mal.

But your post has convinced me they a both equally undeserving of the Immortal title.

 

[Jean Capdouze]

Yes in my original post I was going to say it's a coin toss between Wally and Mal.

But your post has convinced me they a both equally undeserving of the Immortal title.

And who are you exactly & what have you offered the game?

 

[Diesel]

Mal “what has rugby league done for me” Meninga

 

[mongoose]

Dally Messenger - couldn't even win a Dally M.

 

[Eelementary]

Wally Lewis would be my pick.

How many other immortals had their clubs win back to back premierships after kicking their ass to the curb?

Brett Kenny was thrice the player Lewis was, tbh.

 

[lynx000]

Johns for sure.