Who was better ?

[de$$ie]

Robertson. Pretty dependable, couple of GF's.

Todd Carney or Anthony Mundine?

Carney, as big of a dickhead he is, he doesn't have shit on Mundine.

Brendon Reeves or Brent Webb?

 

[POPEYE]

Webb

Would you rather Grothe hampered by bad knees or a tougher Ribot with better stats

 

[Brutus]

Webb

Would you rather Grothe hampered by bad knees or a tougher Ribot with better stats

Ribot because he used to lead with the forearm whilst running the ball.


Brad Williams or Graeme Atkins.

 

[Loudstrat]

You have a boner whenever Ribot's name is metioned.

 

[Brutus]

You have a boner whenever Ribot's name is metioned.

You get wet whenever Kevin Humphries' name is mentioned.

 

[Iafeta]

Woods. Could have been anything in a decent side.

Meli - 4 tries in a semi

Soward or Orford?

5 tries actually

 

[TheDalek079]

Fairfax, Schubert, Boustead or Minichiello?

 

[Brutus]

Fairfax, Schubert, Boustead or Minichiello?

Minichielo, closely followed by Bowie.

Joel Caine or Shannon Nevin.

 

[macnaz]

Minichielo, closely followed by Bowie.

Joel Caine or Shannon Nevin.

Lol funny u brought this one up , I was thinking of doing the same .
I thought Nevin was a tough classy little player .. beats Caine

Matt Parish or Daniel Fitzhenry at five eight ?

 

[Brutus]

Lol funny u brought this one up , I was thinking of doing the same .
I thought Nevin was a tough classy little player .. beats Caine

Matt Parish or Daniel Fitzhenry at five eight ?

Battle of the mullets. Fitzhenry gets the nod due to superior wicket-keeping ability in the Sydney first grade cricket comp.

Kevin Hardwick or Kerry Hemsley.

 

[macnaz]

Battle of the mullets. Fitzhenry gets the nod due to superior wicket-keeping ability in the Sydney first grade cricket comp.

Kevin Hardwick or Kerry Hemsley.

Buckets Hemsley gets the nod.
Larry Corowa or Chicka Ferguson ?

 

[The Eagle]

Buckets Hemsley gets the nod.
Larry Corowa or Chicka Ferguson ?

Chicka

BM or Moffo

 

[TheDalek079]

Moffo.

Davey Warner or Kevin Pietersen

 

[Red Bear]

KP

Tim Brasher or Brett Mullins?

 

[Parra]

KP

Tim Brasher or Brett Mullins?

Mullins by a mile.

1 Eyed Tezza from page one:

Benji Marshall vs Brett Kenny

That is not even a real question.




Denis Fitzgerald vs Geoff Gerard

 

[beave]

Geoff Gerard


Willie Carne or Mick Hancock?

 

[TheDalek079]

Can't remember much about Crossan, but I remember Wishart going ok. So I'll say Wishart.


Brett Kenny, John Peard or Laurie Daley?

 

[Brutus]

Geoff Gerard


Willie Carne or Mick Hancock?

Hancock for longevity and the fact he didn't go to union. Carne around 91-94 was brilliant though.

Andrew Farrar or Chris Mortimer

 

[beave]

Can't remember much about Crossan, but I remember Wishart going ok. So I'll say Wishart.


Brett Kenny, John Peard or Laurie Daley?

Sorry mate, i put up Crossan and Wishart but remembered i asked the same question about a year ago amd changed it to Carne v Hancock.


Brett Kenny

 

[beave]

Hancock for longevity and the fact he didn't go to union. Carne around 91-94 was brilliant though.

Andrew Farrar or Chris Mortimer

Mortimer because he played 2 more origin games than Farrar.


Gary Larson or Billy Moore?