Who was better ?

[Brutus]

Luke Priddis, easily.

Lockyer v Slater (as fullbacks)

Slater.

Kevin Walters v Cliff Lyons.

 

[DiegoNT]

Slater.

Kevin Walters v Cliff Lyons.

Cliffy
SKD or steve matai

 

[typicalfan]

Matai.

Daryl Halligan or Lee Oudenryn

 

[Captain Apollo]

Matai.

Daryl Halligan or Lee Oudenryn

Halligan by a few lengths.

Matt Adamson or Phil Adamson.

 

[anjado]

Matt Adamson easily.

David Woods or Stuart Kelly ?

 

[typicalfan]

David Woods.

Danny Crnkovich or Peter McPhail.

 

[Rhyno]

Crnkovich

Eric Grothe JR or Manu Vatuvei

 

[TheDalek079]

Vatuvei.



Todd Byrne or Wes Naiqama?

 

[Rhyno]

Byrne

Luke Burt or Matt Bowen

 

[DiegoNT]

Byrne

Luke Burt or Matt Bowen

Matt bowen by far

Marcus bai or matt Geyer

 

[typicalfan]

Matt bowen by far

Marcus bai or matt Geyer

Bai.

Laurie Daley or Brett Kenny.

 

[Gerggerggerg]

Lyon, Daylight, then Hodges

Matt Daylight was a better centre than Hodges? Big call, sir.

 

[Rhyno]

Bai.

Laurie Daley or Brett Kenny.

Kenny.

Peter Sterling or Steve Mortimer

 

[Brutus]

Matt bowen by far

Marcus bai or matt Geyer

Matt Geyer

Des Hasler or Geoff Toovey

 

[typicalfan]

Kenny.

Peter Sterling or Steve Mortimer

Sterlo

Graham Mackey or Michael Erickson

 

[Captain Apollo]

Matt Geyer

Des Hasler or Geoff Toovey

Toovey.

Sterlo

Graham Mackey or Michael Erickson

Mackey.

Steve Edge or Benny Elias?

 

[Craig Johnston]

Sterlo

Graham Mackey or Michael Erickson

mackay seriously under-rated player he was

chook herron or adrian brunker?

 

[roostersrule2]

Toovey.



Mackey.

Steve Edge or Benny Elias?

Elias.

Sandow or Albert Kelly.

 

[betcats]

Elias.

Sandow or Albert Kelly.

Sandow.

Ben Hunt or Michael Morgan?

 

[anjado]

Ben Hunt is quite a bit better in my opinion

Also Mackay was an awesome player being compared to someone like Michael Erickson is a massive insult.

Sticking to the Penrith vs Parramatta theme

Paul Smith or Jason Moodie ?