Who was better ?

[Captain Apollo]

Both were fantastic loyal players but I would just give it to Menzies due to his strike rate and that he won a couple of premierships. Plus I've never been a Manly fan but Ive always liked them because of this man.

Sam Burgess v Adrian Morely

Morley. Helped get his side to 3 Grand Finals even if they only won 1. Burgess only played in 1 GF.

 

[Craig Johnston]

Jeremy smith or Jeremy smith?

 

[anjado]

Craig Teevan - He played for queensland and had a decent career i could be wrong about Rohan though i only remember him as a reserve grader.

Jeremy Smith the ex Storm current Newcastle one.


Adrian Lam or Mitchell Pearce ?

 

[roostersrule2]

Craig Teevan - He played for queensland and had a decent career i could be wrong about Rohan though i only remember him as a reserve grader.

Jeremy Smith the ex Storm current Newcastle one.


Adrian Lam or Mitchell Pearce ?

Pearce.

Jake Friend or Farah?

 

[anjado]

I would still take Robbie Farah though i could see Jake Friend surpassing him one day.

Darren Smith or Justin Hodges ?

 

[ram raid]

Hodges.

Garry Belcher or Brett Mullins ?

 

[Brutus]

Hodges.

Garry Belcher or Brett Mullins ?

Gary Belcher. More consistent and ripper of a dummy. Loved Badge as a player.

 

[Craig Johnston]

Hodges.

Garry Belcher or Brett Mullins ?

both more decorated and accomplished fullbacks than lockyer

 

[Bulldog Force]

Who was better: Lote or Wendell?

 

[Mogsheen Jadwat]

Wendell

both more decorated and accomplished fullbacks than lockyer

did lockyer take your lunch money as a kid or something?

 

[Craig Johnston]

Wendell




did lockyer take your lunch money as a kid or something?

That's one way to look at it....

Or it could be a massive wrap for badge and mullo

The way the Broncos treated badge was disgraceful

 

[Mogsheen Jadwat]

what, sacked him as fitness coach cause they were fading at the back end of the season for years on end?

Seemed like a good decision as they won the premiership the next year.

 

[Craig Johnston]

what, sacked him as fitness coach cause they were fading at the back end of the season for years on end?

Seemed like a good decision as they won the premiership the next year.

scapegoat for other people's shit performances

 

[Mogsheen Jadwat]

lol that's a poor response even by your standards

 

[DiegoNT]

Mitchell Pearce or adam Reynolds?.
Preferably from someone other than rabbitohs and roosters fans

 

[mongoose]

Mitchell Pearce or adam Reynolds?.
Preferably from someone other than rabbitohs and roosters fans

Tough one... I would rather have Reynolds in my team.

Trent Barret or Scott Hill

 

[TheDalek079]

Barrett. For the faceslap

Billy Smith or Alfie?

 

[Jimmy-o]

Aaron Payne or Piggy Riddell?

 

[ram raid]

Aaron Payne or Piggy Riddell?

Payne.

Hodges or Lyon?

 

[chigurh]

Hodges.

Jesse Brom or JWH?