Who was better ?

[CliffyIsGod]

Clyde by the length of the straight

Sean Rudder or Shane Perry

 

[Desert Qlder]

Rudder, for longevity.

Stacey Jones or Benji Marshall?

 

[JJ]

Clyde

Gene Miles or Hodges

 

[JJ]

Rudder, for longevity.

Stacey Jones or Benji Marshall?

Jones q above

 

[Tommy Smith]

Taumalolo is as damaging a ball running forward I've ever seen. It's easy to say Clyde because he's a legend but if I could pick one on my team it'd be JT.

Gene Miles for sure.

Adrian Morley or JWH

 

[Joeboy]

Jwh. Although injuries have wreaked havoc with him recently.

Eion crossan vs Ian "chook" herron

 

[JJ]

Herron

Matthew Ridge or Gary Jack

 

[Seage]

Jack. Ridge was a cheap shot merchant.

Wes Patten or Leo Dynevor?

 

[Vic Mackey]

Jack. Ridge was a cheap shot merchant.

Wes Patten or Leo Dynevor?

Dynevor looked like a very good halfback, shouldn't have gone to wests, if he went to a more stable team he could have had a career.

Patten was nothing more then a 7s player.

Nathan blacklock or David peachey?

 

[Tommy Smith]

Tingha. His try scoring record, particularly for like a 3 or 4 year span, was absolutely remarkable. He wasn't a good defender but as a pure winger he's the most instinctive I've seen. His chip and chase to win a game vs the Tigers stands out to me still.

David Solomona or Dean Widders

 

[Rhino_NQ]

solomona

zane musgrove or any rugby league player that ever lived

 

[dangerousdave]

solomona

zane musgrove or any rugby league player that ever lived

Too tough to call.

John Simon or Noel Goldthorpe?

 

[Dogs Of War]

Too tough to call.

John Simon or Noel Goldthorpe?

Geez, too easy, Noel Goldthorpe. John Simon was so overweight most of his career, although he had talent, he just never gave it a chance. Goldthorpe played in some very good Dragons team, even played SoO.


EDIT: Which of the Walters brothers was best?

 

[nick87]

Steve and its not particularly close.

Ash Taylor or Nathan Cleary?

 

[TheDalek079]

at the moment Ash Taylor.


Gary Freeman or Brent Sherwin?

 

[Rhino_NQ]

sherwin

ryan o'hara or richard villasanti?

 

[myrrh ken]

villasanti reached a higher height for a shorter time.

Luke Covell or Eion Crossan or Chook Herron?

EDIT - Ah, that's already been done!

Tulson Tollett v Daniel Mortimer?

 

[no name]

Geez, too easy, Noel Goldthorpe. John Simon was so overweight most of his career, although he had talent, he just never gave it a chance. Goldthorpe played in some very good Dragons team, even played SoO.


EDIT: Which of the Walters brothers was best?

Goldthorpe never played Origin, Simon did however.

 

[myrrh ken]

Goldthorpe never played Origin, Simon did however.

Super league tri-series. Only kicked 1 field goal from memory. Simon kicked 3 in a game from memory.

Anyway answer the bloody question!

 

[Mogsheen Jadwat]

goldthorpe played in the awful tri-series origin in SL, i believe he kicked the winner in ET golden point.