Who was better ?

[no name]

Sorry to sidetrack the thread.

Super league tri-series. Only kicked 1 field goal from memory. Simon kicked 3 in a game from memory.

Anyway answer the bloody question!

That's not Origin.

 

[myrrh ken]

Sorry to sidetrack the thread.


That's not Origin.

Correct, you pedant. I'm sure he meant NSW.

T Tollett v D Mortimer

 

[no name]

Correct, you pedant. I'm sure he meant NSW.

T Tollett v D Mortimer

He used Origin as a reason why Goldthorpe was better than Simon, when in fact Simon had played and Goldthorpe hadn't. Just couldn't let that one go.

Mortimer from what I can remember of Tollet. Mortimer has had a couple of periods of decent footy at the back ends of '09 and '13.

Paul Osborne or George Rose?

 

[Glendale]

Rose

Akuila Uate (in his prime) or Semi Radradra of nowadays?

 

[dangerousdave]

Uate's 'prime' was pretty short lived.

Rara by the length of the straight if he turns up next season.

Tim Brasher or Robbie O'Davis?

 

[SBD82]

Uate's 'prime' was pretty short lived.

Rara by the length of the straight if he turns up next season.

Tim Brasher or Robbie O'Davis?

Brasher. Would have had an even longer Roos career if not for Lockyer.

Amos Roberts or Nathan blacklock?

 

[Desert Qlder]

Uate's 'prime' was pretty short lived.

Rara by the length of the straight if he turns up next season.

Tim Brasher or Robbie O'Davis?

That's a good one actually.

Have to go with Brasher, at his peak he was an electrifying player.

Joe Thomas or Kerrod Walters?

 

[Desert Qlder]

Brasher. Would have had an even longer Roos career if not for Lockyer.

Amos Roberts or Nathan blacklock?

Blacklock easy.

Joe Thomas or Kerrod Walters?

 

[BM1979]

Walters by the length of the straight IMO

Josh Morris or Chris Johns

 

[THE CHAMP]

I'll go Morris just.
Mark gasnier or Steve renouf

 

[axl rose]

Blacklock easy.

Joe Thomas or Kerrod Walters?

K Walters, very underrated. Unlike his brother Steve who was a myth.

 

[dangerousdave]

Gaz at his peak was probably better. Better defender too. But the foray into union is a real killer. Shortened his career by 2 seasons and therefore this one goes to the Pearl for consistency and longevity.

Tonie Carrol or Ben Kennedy?

 

[jc155776]

Ben Kennedy.

More of an all round game than Carrol who spent his time as Lockys bodyguard.

Michael Sullivan vs Anthony Watts

 

[Rhino_NQ]

as much of a twat he is anthony watts was better (when played in his actual position, had some nightmares at fullback for us). Landed a few on farahs chin has to get you points as well.

fuifui moimoi or iafeta paleaasina

 

[CliffyIsGod]

Fui

Sione Faumuina or Feleti Mateo

 

[Rhino_NQ]

mateo, feleti occasionally looked where he was passing

kris kahler or ben czislowski

 

[CliffyIsGod]

ben czislowski -- his name will live on longer

Tony Puletua or Joe Gulavao

 

[myrrh ken]

Big Joe. Was the top prop back in the day but declined fairly quickly and then just hung around way too long.

Danny Crnkovich or Anthony Xuereb?

 

[Tommy Smith]

Never heard of 'em. Don't be silly.

Jackson Kaufusi, Lipina Kaufusi or Makasini Richter?

 

[CliffyIsGod]

Jackson

Shaun Wessell or Don Tweedle