Who was better ?

[typicalfan]

Gidley

Kenny or Lockyer?

Brett Kenny over Lockyer

Lockyer over Nick Kenny.

Robbie O'Davis or David Peachey.

 

[mozza91]

Brett Kenny over Lockyer

Lockyer over Nick Kenny.

Robbie O'Davis or David Peachey.

Robbie O

Jake Trbojevic or Cam Murray?

 

[The unknown]

Trbojevic

James Graham or Sam Burgess

 

[Vee]

Trbojevic

James Graham or Sam Burgess

Tough call. Graham was better years ago when he used the ball. Sam is better than just about anyone else when he's on but his hands can let him down and I would have penalised him out of the game.

Graham.

Sterlo or Turvey?

 

[Captain Apollo]

Tough call. Graham was better years ago when he used the ball. Sam is better than just about anyone else when he's on but his hands can let him down and I would have penalised him out of the game.

Graham.

Sterlo or Turvey?

Sterlo.

Eric Grothe (Sr) or John Ferguson?

 

[TheDalek079]

Guru


Jake Friend or Craig Wing?

 

[The unknown]

Tough call. Graham was better years ago when he used the ball. Sam is better than just about anyone else when he's on but his hands can let him down and I would have penalised him out of the game.

Graham.

Yeah so hard to split. Both great assets to their respective teams back in the day (past it now), but id say Graham gets the nod at their peaks for ball playing ability

 

[King hit]

Guru


Jake Friend or Craig Wing?

Craig Wing by far. Probably the best utility player I've ever seen

 

[Tommy Smith]

Fonua Blake or Josh Papalii?

 

[typicalfan]

Fonua Blake or Josh Papalii?

Josh Papalii.

Marc Glanville or Owen Cunningham.

 

[myrrh ken]

Josh Papalii.

Marc Glanville or Owen Cunningham.

cunningham

Greg Inglis or Greg Bird

 

[Vee]

Greg Inglis or Greg Bird

you're joking, right?

 

[myrrh ken]

you're joking, right?

No different to comparing Fonua Blake and Josh Papalii.

 

[Vee]

No different to comparing Fonua Blake and Josh Papalii.

Disagree. Both Blake and Papa have only come good in the last year or two.

 

[horrie hastings]

Sterlo.

Eric Grothe (Sr) or John Ferguson?

Geez two great wingers, the pure strength and speed for such a big man for Eric Grothe and the side stepping and eluviness of John Ferguson. I am so glad I had the opportunity to watch both at the top of their games, I Just wish John Ferguson would have played in a better Easts side while he was with the tri colours.

 

[typicalfan]

cunningham

Greg Inglis or Greg Bird

Greg Inglis.

Terry Hill or Paul Bowman

 

[myrrh ken]

Disagree. Both Blake and Papa have only come good in the last year or two.

whoosh

 

[Vee]

Greg Inglis.

Terry Hill or Paul Bowman

Hill had more talent but Bear was more reliable.

 

[avocado]

Terry Hill was an amazing player. Just spoke funny. “The atmosphere is electronic!”

Kurt Sorrenson or Les Boyd.

 

[myrrh ken]

Kurt Sorensen was a legend. Boyd was just a thug.

Craig Gower or Julian O'Neill?