Who was better ?

[The unknown]

Craig Gower

Ryan Matterson or Mitchell Moses?

 

[Tommy Smith]

Mitchell Moses.

No different to comparing Fonua Blake and Josh Papalii.

How so?

Fonua Blake is an absolute beast. One of the elite forwards of the NRL.

Radradra or Fergo?

 

[myrrh ken]

How so?

Fonua Blake is an absolute beast. One of the elite forwards of the NRL.

Hits hard and is a good kicker. Just ask his missus.

 

[Generalzod]

Craig Gower

Ryan Matterson or Mitchell Moses?

This Moses

 

[Captain Apollo]

Mitchell Moses.


How so?

Fonua Blake is an absolute beast. One of the elite forwards of the NRL.

Radradra or Fergo?

Fergo. He at least won a premiership and didn't piss off to Union for a money grab at the first sign.

Steve Ella or Chris Close?

 

[Vic Mackey]

Fergo. He at least won a premiership and didn't piss off to Union for a money grab at the first sign.

Steve Ella or Chris Close?

I started watching footy just after these guys were in their prime but what ive seen/heard gotta go Ella

Michael Crocker or Craig Fitzgibbon?

 

[Tommy Smith]

Fitzgibbon, easily.

Gareth Ellis or John Bateman?

 

[mozza91]

Ellis. In a few years time it’ll be a different story.

Ricky Stuart or Cooper Cronk?

 

[typicalfan]

Ellis. In a few years time it’ll be a different story.

Ricky Stuart or Cooper Cronk?

Sticky more skilful, Cronk more durable. I lean slightly towards Cronk for his ultra professionalism.

Matt Seers or Clinton Schifcofske.

 

[King hit]

Schifcofske

Excellent all round player with a great boot. Very underrated. From what I’ve seen of Seers he was more suited to broken play.

Wendell Sailor or Lote Tuquri

 

[SBD82]

Schifcofske

Excellent all round player with a great boot. Very underrated. From what I’ve seen of Seers he was more suited to broken play.

Wendell Sailor or Lote Tuquri

Sailor. No sleight on Tuqiri, but there’s a lot of wingers that have now modelled their game on the hard work that Sailor did coming off the line.

Miller or Gallen?

 

[T-Boon]

Women’s volleyball or Netball?

 

[Vic Mackey]

Sailor. No sleight on Tuqiri, but there’s a lot of wingers that have now modelled their game on the hard work that Sailor did coming off the line.

Miller or Gallen?

Although he’s a merkin you can’t go past Gallen. Miller was a good player but the likes of Pearce, Price and Vautin generally shaded him


Luke O’Donnell or Stephen Kearney?

 

[mongoose]

Although he’s a merkin you can’t go past Gallen. Miller was a good player but the likes of Pearce, Price and Vautin generally shaded him


Luke O’Donnell or Stephen Kearney?

Kearney, O' Donnell was a thug

Anthony Milford or Shaun Johnson?

 

[typicalfan]

Kearney, O' Donnell was a thug

Anthony Milford or Shaun Johnson?

Really hard, I think it comes down to peak Johnson, when that happens is better than peak Milford. So Johnson.

David Howell or Jamahl Lolesi.

 

[myrrh ken]

Really hard, I think it comes down to peak Johnson, when that happens is better than peak Milford. So Johnson.

David Howell or Jamahl Lolesi.

Lolesi - purely on the fact that he played more NRL games. Also played for Kiwis.

Paul Carige v Kurt Mann

 

[mozza91]

Lolesi - purely on the fact that he played more NRL games. Also played for Kiwis.

Paul Carige v Kurt Mann

I’d take Paul Carige now over Mann.

Jarryd Hayne or Justin Hodges?

 

[mongoose]

Hayne at his peak was better but Hodges had a better career so I'll go Hodges.

Karmichael Hunt or Israel Folau ?

 

[typicalfan]

Hayne at his peak was better but Hodges had a better career so I'll go Hodges.

Karmichael Hunt or Israel Folau ?

Folau was better 2/3 codes.

Matt Orford or Brent Sherwin.

 

[SBD82]

Folau was better 2/3 codes.

Matt Orford or Brent Sherwin.

Orford.

O’Meley or Klemmer?