Who was better?

[Misanthrope]

Bully Ray. Would not look out of place in the WWE title scene.

Batista or Ryback?

 

[Scott Gourley's Lovechild]

Batista, great heel and a good babyface. Ryback, while pushed to 9 10ths of the moon, really hasn't hit the same highs or ring ability of Batista.

Daniel Bryan or Bryan Danielson

 

[deemac77]

Daniel Bryan, NO!!

Mike Awesome or Jake Roberts

 

[Abz]

Jake Roberts - loved the snake gimmick

Stone Cold Steve Austin or Hulk Hogan?

 

[Misanthrope]

Austin. Not quite as overbooked as Hogan.

Stacy Kiebler or AJ?

 

[Abz]

That's a tough one. AJ is this cute petite hot psycho with a baby face, where as Stacy is just FREAKIN HOT. Not just a little hot, but SO FREAKING EFFING HOT with a mature face. Stacy by a landslide.

George Clooney doesn't know what a lucky son-of-a-bitch he is.

Undertaker PG Era or Undertaker Attitude Era? (Don't use the era you like, use when you thought he was better).

 

[afinalsin666]

PG undertaker. The experience is his best asset the past few years.

Mark Henry or Kane?

 

[jc155776]

Kane but only when wearing a mask.

Jamie Noble or Jimmy Wang Yang

 

[Misanthrope]

Jamie Noble. Loved his work.

Christian or Chris Benoit?

 

[Scott Gourley's Lovechild]

Christian. He can actually cut a promo!

Matt Morgan or Rhyno

 

[Misanthrope]

Matt Morgan. Rhino is/was overrated.

Samoa Joe or Jack Swagger?

 

[Abz]

Samoa Joe is a better worker. If Swagger was in TNA, he'd be so bad.

Brother Ray or Scott Steiner?

 

[Misanthrope]

Brother Ray. Can work a match and talk. Steiner's just... steroids.

Roddy Piper or Ted DiBiase?

 

[Pugzley]

Piper. Stone Cold prototype.

Battle of the Spot Monkeys

Air Boom or The Young Bucks?

 

[Scott Gourley's Lovechild]

Young Bucks on longevity and their great ability to look like those midgets Edge and Christian brought out to impersonate the Hardy Boyz.

Chainsaw Charlie or Brother Love

 

[Abz]

Haven't heard of either so I'll go Chainsaw Charlie.

British Bulldog or Sheamus?

 

[Scott Gourley's Lovechild]

Bulldog, the man was a very good hand and could play heel or face. Sheamus makes a good heel, but is a horrid face.

Bad Influence or Edge and Christian

 

[Misanthrope]

Bad Influence. Better individual workers (Edge is horribly overrated IMO).

Team Hell No or Kane & X-Pac?

 

[Big Pete]

Hell No every day of the week.

X-Pac/Kane was such a 'we've got nothing better to do with these guys, let's put them together' tag team and it really hurt Kane's character in the long run.

Team Hell No basically saved his character.

Louie Spicolli vs. Devon Storm (Crowbar) - Clash of the mid 90s ECW guys who crop up as underrated performers.

Matt Morgan. Rhino is/was overrated.

What does that make Matt Morgan?

Brother Ray. Can work a match and talk. Steiner's just... steroids.

Damn, no love for early 90s Steiner?

 

[Misanthrope]

What does that make Matt Morgan?

I still think Morgan is just a guy waiting for the right moment. There's never been a concerted effort to push him, really. He's fallen prey to injuries, God awful booking, and in one case - his own lack of motivation.

Louie Spicolli vs. Devon Storm (Crowbar) - Clash of the mid 90s ECW guys who crop up as underrated performers.

I never saw a lot of Spicolli's work, so Devon Storm gets the nod from me based on the virtue of his WCW work.

Lacey von Erich or Melina?