Who was better?

[Old Timer]

Who was less "Shit"?

Smith was the smaller turd

 

[dannyt]

Smith was the smaller turd

LOL

 

[dannyt]

Mathews
John Simon or Hornby

Hornby

Poore and Leikvoll?

 

[RedVDragon]

Poore

Phil Blake or Widdop

 

[Slippery Morris]

Phil Blake

Joel Thompson or Darren Treacy

 

[Country Dragon]

Phil Blake

Joel Thompson or Darren Treacy

Treacy.

Langlands or Gasnier?

 

[BennyV]

Treacy.

Langlands or Gasnier?

Gasnier. Not that I saw either of them play, but I was fortunate enough to have lunch with Johnny Raper a few months back, he stated (in no uncertain terms) that Reg was the greatest player to ever play the game, and that he could walk into the NRL today he would dominate the modern era.

Dean Young or Shaun Timmins?

 

[Uplifting]

Gasnier. Not that I saw either of them play, but I was fortunate enough to have lunch with Johnny Raper a few months back, he stated (in no uncertain terms) that Reg was the greatest player to ever play the game, and that he could walk into the NRL today he would dominate the modern era.

Dean Young or Shaun Timmins?

Dean Young
How about theses two emerging players who didn't play FG due to injury. Who was/would've been better:
Rex Terp or Evander Cummins?

 

[GC Dragon]

Evander Cummins for me .

Eddie Lumsden and Johnny King .

 

[KiamaSaint]

Evander Cummins for me .

Eddie Lumsden and Johnny King .

So tough, King.

The General or Amos Roberts.

 

[SBD82]

So tough, King.

The General or Amos Roberts.

Roberts. For the excitement factor. The bloke could find an intercept.

But if Patten had spent his career in the red v I think he might have become a dragons legend. Great club man.

Girdler or Mary?

 

[Country Dragon]

Roberts. For the excitement factor. The bloke could find an intercept.

But if Patten had spent his career in the red v I think he might have become a dragons legend. Great club man.

Girdler or Mary?

Mary, but his reputation is suffering the more he sticks around!

Peter Gill or Ian Russell?

 

[Saint_JimmyG]

Saffy in 2010.

Matt Head or Brett Firman?

Gimme Head everyday of the week (including weekends).

Continuing the halfback theme.....

Alchin or Hodges?

 

[Old Timer]

Evander Cummins for me .

Eddie Lumsden and Johnny King .

Lumsden was the Eric Grothe of his day.
Big, strong, fast, long stride, great fend and got down low as the tackler arrived and was able to bump them off and continue on to the line.

King was not so fast but a super professional finisher and he too had a wonderful ability to turn his hip into the tackler to bump them off and not change ,his normal stride. King was the absolute master of crash tackling players often in a cover defensive role on the opposite wing.
Many a time Cleary thought he was going to score only to be smashed over the sideline by King.
Both wonderful players and I was blessed to see both of them and the more I think about them I really think this one is a dead heat.

 

[SBD82]

Gimme Head everyday of the week (including weekends).

Continuing the halfback theme.....

Alchin or Hodges?

Alchin. But I'm not confident. It's a long time ago.

Jason Stevens or Jason ryles?

 

[Miller was a legend]

Alchin. But I'm not confident. It's a long time ago.

Jason Stevens or Jason ryles?

Stevens. He has God on his side.

 

[getsmarty]

Stevens. He has God on his side.

Always admired Stevens as a player.

 

[SBD82]

Stevens. He has God on his side.

Thought you'd be too busy celebrating to be slumming it in here millers.

Congrats on the win mate. Good luck next week.

You know the rules though.., you have to ask a question after you answer. Not even grand finalist teams' fans are exempt.

 

[Miller was a legend]

Thought you'd be too busy celebrating to be slumming it in here millers.

Congrats on the win mate. Good luck next week.

You know the rules though.., you have to ask a question after you answer. Not even grand finalist teams' fans are exempt.

Ahh sorry mate and thanks.

Trouble is I am a massive Billy Smith fan. Idolise him. None are better in my eyes

 

[SBD82]

Ahh sorry mate and thanks.

Trouble is I am a massive Billy Smith fan. Idolise him. None are better in my eyes

Ha. Ok. One in honor of the sharkies then...

Matt Prior or Lance Thompson