Who was better?

[SBD82]

Saffy in 2010.

Matt Head or Brett Firman?

I'm glad you edited that. Thought I was having a memory blank.

Matt head.

M Gasnier or M Cooper?

 

[BringTheNoise]

I'm glad you edited that. Thought I was having a memory blank.

Matt head.

M Gasnier or M Cooper?

Gasnier.

Riddell or Fein?

 

[Dragsters]

Gasnier.

Riddell or Fein?

Piggy

Bailey or Ryles?

 

[BrissyRedV]

Piggy

Bailey or Ryles?

Bull

Bartrim or Timmins

 

[Slippery Morris]

Tough call but I will go Timmins

Coach Farrah or Coach Brown?

 

[BennyV]

Certainly not easy to split imo. I had to have a look on YouTube to refresh my memory and what great memories the highlights brought back. I stick by my summation, when I think of tingha I think the freak. When I think of BMOZ I think the finisher. Just some quick try scoring stats:
Tingha 137 games for the Dragons for 120 tries
Bmoz 169 games for the Dragons for 114 tries
Bmoz obviously has the upper hand in rep games etc.

The stats you highlight indicate Tingah is the better finisher. He had a great knack for knowing where to be and when.
But if you look at the wingers job as a whole - defence, cover, metres/scoots - then Morris was far above.

 

[God-King Dean]

Tough call but I will go Timmins

Coach Farrah or Coach Brown?

Brown. I mean... Cmon!

Leo Clarke or Wise Kativerata ?

 

[dannyt]

Wise

Slippery Morris vs. BMoz?

 

[DragonsBlood]

Slippers

Troy Perkins or "The Fridge" Colin Saukuru?

 

[Slippery Morris]

Slippery by a mile and not cause of my name. He was a quality halfback and winger. Reason I went for the red V was because of this guy.

Worst signing -
Nathan Long or Albert Torrens?

 

[Slippery Morris]

Home and Away or Neighbours?

 

[BrissyRedV]

The stats you highlight indicate Tingah is the better finisher. He had a great knack for knowing where to be and when.
But if you look at the wingers job as a whole - defence, cover, metres/scoots - then Morris was far above.

All valid points, but you still haven't swayed me. 2 Red V legends.

 

[BringTheNoise]

Home and Away or Neighbours?

Neighbours.

Coach Nathan Brown or Brian Smith?

 

[Dragsters]

Slippery by a mile and not cause of my name. He was a quality halfback and winger. Reason I went for the red V was because of this guy.

Worst signing -
Nathan Long or Albert Torrens?

Nathan Long.

Albert Torrens played 10 times as many games as Long.

Nathan Long or Luke Page?
(Both one game wonders)

 

[Eatons Hill Dragon]

Nathan Long.

Albert Torrens played 10 times as many games as Long.

Nathan Long or Luke Page?
(Both one game wonders)

Flip a coin, Nathan Long is the winner.

Mitch Rein or Trevor Bailey ?

 

[Country Dragon]

Flip a coin, Nathan Long is the winner.

Mitch Rein or Trevor Bailey ?

Trevor Bailey.
Tony Smith or Benji?

 

[Old Timer]

Trevor Bailey.
Tony Smith or Benji?

Both shit in the big red v
Jarrod Saffy v Will Matthews

 

[SBD82]

Both shit in the big red v
Jarrod Saffy v Will Matthews

Saffy. Played his role well in the pack.

Riolo or Patten?

 

[Country Dragon]

Both shit in the big red v
Jarrod Saffy v Will Matthews

Who was less "Shit"?

 

[Belta]

Mathews
John Simon or Hornby