Who was in the wrong?

[JoeysChiropractor]

PJ Marsh, shouldn't be leading with the elbow, even though it hit the shoulder of Barrett first, it didn't stop much force and he copped it across the face. I'm sure many players would react in a similar fashion, perhaps not hitting him from behind, but if Marsh didn't make contact like he didnt, there wouldn't have been any fighting.

 

[Kiwi]

PJ Marsh, shouldn't be leading with the elbow, even though it hit the shoulder of Barrett first, it didn't stop much force and he copped it across the face. I'm sure many players would react in a similar fashion, perhaps not hitting him from behind, but if Marsh didn't make contact like he didnt, there wouldn't have been any fighting.

Kennedy would have played dead.

 

[RABK]

Well for starters Marsh would have been taken off via the medicab.

:LOL:

 

[Lego_Man]

Where is the "both" option?

 

[White Poiner]

can i ask the audience?

 

[shadow grinder]

barret deserves 12-18 weeks...no less

 

[Phillips]

barret deserves 12-18 weeks...no less

 

[Deacon]

shadow grinder and Phillips dead set comedians

 

[Jordan]

It was a spur of the moment thing and obviously Trent Barrett saw a elbow coming his way or he wouldn't have reacted how he did. I'm still not convinced that there was no contact with his head either. There is no conclusive replay showing the contact that we saw, but in some of the replays (like the camera angle behind Barrett) it looks like his head bounces back just when Marsh's elbow passes his face, which could indicate some contact.

 

[Tommy Smith]

PJ Marsh came in with a blatant and intentional elbow to the head. And Barrett overreacted with a couple of blind-sided cheap shots.

Then, Cayless was the third man in - something Finch got binned and suspended for - so all in all it should have been a penalty to the Dragons.

 

[shadow grinder]

shadow grinder and Phillips dead set comedians

thanks.

 

[Phillips]

Then, Cayless was the third man in - something Finch got binned and suspended for - so all in all it should have been a penalty to the Dragons.

what did you expect, for the captain to just stand there and watch someone cheapshot a team mate?

 

[shadow grinder]

what did you expect, for the captain to just stand there and watch someone cheapshot a team mate?

not only once but THREE times.

also the last punch got marsh in the temple.....if barret had got a hard enough punch on him marsh could have been knocked out or even killed. barret had plenty of time to stop ...but he continued on like a thug he is

 

[Tommy Smith]

not only once but THREE times.

also the last punch got marsh in the temple.....if barret had got a hard enough punch on him marsh could have been knocked out or even killed. barret had plenty of time to stop ...but he continued on like a thug he is

Knock him out? Kill him?

Didn't you see the way Barrett punched? He couldn't put a dint in a Kleenex.

 

[shadow grinder]

Knock him out? Kill him?

Didn't you see the way Barrett punched? He couldn't put a dint in a Kleenex.

:lol:

thats why i said "if he had got a hard enough punch on him" ...if it were someone who could throw them i bet marsh would have been knocked out.

 

[Lenny_2212]

what did you expect, for the captain to just stand there and watch someone cheapshot a team mate?

cayless ran in and gave greenshields a nice forearm to the face. dirty thug.

lol.

 

[shadow grinder]

typical dragon...likes to give it to other guys from behind

 

[Lenny_2212]

typical dragon...likes to give it to other guys from behind

typical homosexual, takes a serious topic and throws in a sentence like that.

 

[Y2Eel]

typical homosexual, takes a serious topic and throws in a sentence like that.

you saying the barret is a typical homosexual continuing from shadow grinder post?

typical dragon...likes to give it to other guys from behind

typical homosexual.

 

[shadow grinder]

typical homosexual, takes a serious topic and throws in a sentence like that.

im not the one giving it to other players from behind...thats your mob!!