Who's better?

[Ghostface Killah]

Post the name of two players, the next poster answers then posts the names of another two players, and so on and so forth...

I'll begin:

- Reg Gasnier; or
- Mal Meninga

 

[Dogs Of War]

Way too hard cause I never saw Reg play and I'm fairly old already.

So I'm taking Mal.

Cliff Lyons
Terry Lamb

 

[Cheese sandwich]

Way too hard cause I never saw Reg play and I'm fairly old already.

So I'm taking Mal.

Cliff Lyons
Terry Lamb

Cliffy

Danny Crnkovich
Greg Barwick

 

[Dogs Of War]

Cliffy

Danny Crnkovich
Greg Barwick

I'm taking Greg just cause it's the last time I ever saw a kicking duel (1989). Him and Gary Belcher at the WACA. Greg flogged him.

 

[Captain Apollo]

Reg and Mal were two very different types of centres. By all reports Reg was lightning quick, relying on speed and evasion to make breaks and set up his winger. Had a good passing game. Was also rock solid in defence.

Mal Meninga was a very good defender too, with a good passing game, but he was more of a power player relying on strength as opposed to speed. Hence I think they are way too different to be able to judge who was "better".

 

[mongoose]

Luke Brooks. or
Mitchel Moses

 

[Someone2]

Moses easily it’s not even a contest

King Gutho
Tedesco

 

[Walpole]

Moses easily it’s not even a contest

King Gutho
Tedesco

Teddy.

Luke Bailey or Jason Ryles.

 

[GC_Gladiator]

Bailey. Consistently good over a number of years.

Mullins or Renouf

 

[I Bleed Maroon]

Not gonna answer that one because clearly I would be biased towards the Pearl. I will leave that up to history to decide.

Steve Menzies or Brett Morris?

 

[Rabbit toes]

Not gonna answer that one because clearly I would be biased towards the Pearl. I will leave that up to history to decide.

Steve Menzies or Brett Morris?

Never heard of the f**kers

 

[myrrh ken]

Beaver. More important position.

Shane Perry vs Chad Townsend vs Sean rudder

 

[Dogs Of War]

Chad Townsend.

Barry Ward
Anthony Mundine

Bonus points if you can work out why I picked that combo of players.

 

[Vee]

Reg and Mal were two very different types of centres. By all reports Reg was lightning quick, relying of speed and evasion to make breaks and set up his winger. Had a good passing game. Was also rock solid in defence.

Mal Meninga was a very good defender too, with a good passing game, but he was more of a power player relying on strength as opposed to speed. Hence I think they are way too different to be able to judge who was "better".

If you could only pick one...

 

[Ghostface Killah]

Chad Townsend.

Barry Ward
Anthony Mundine

Bonus points if you can work out why I picked that combo of players.

Choc for calling out the fat racist f**k.

1. Jack de Belin; or
2. Benny Elias?

 

[Dogs Of War]

Choc for calling out the fat racist f**k.

1. Jack de Belin; or
2. Benny Elias?

It was the moment that Barry Ward was at 5/8th from a scrum move and ran over Anthony Mundine who was telling all and sundry he was the best 5/8th in the world to score a try and was like who is the best 5/8th now with that racist stuff added for effect.

 

[Ghostface Killah]

It was the moment that Barry Ward was at 5/8th from a scrum move and ran over Anthony Mundine who was telling all and sundry he was the best 5/8th in the world to score a try and was like who is the best 5/8th now with that racist stuff added for effect.

Should’ve stayed on the field like Fat Albert’s son and Wobbie.

Anyways, Jackie or Benny?

 

[Captain Apollo]

Should’ve stayed on the field like Fat Albert’s son and Wobbie.

Anyways, Jackie or Benny?

Benny. He all but re-invetnted the way the position was played (even though he could be a selfish ball player).

 

[Ghostface Killah]

Benny. He all but re-invetnted the way the position was played (even though he could be a selfish ball player).

Agreed. Jack’s less selfish and will happily change positions to give his mate a go.

- Arthur Beetson; or
- Glenn Lazarus?

 

[Bobby DIGital]

I'm only 40, so Lazzo.

Rod Wishart or Willie Carne?