We have had quite a few maybe's come through the system and when you look at their highlights you think wow but most have been more or less good in some respects but not in others. Always that attack versus defence thing. They haven't been like Thurston, Johns, Slater, Cronk etc etc., they can win a match for us and score scintillating tries but their poor defensive skills let them down.
Even if you watched highlights of Dufty and Field now playing in Super League, they appear to be killing it, but they are playing Super League which is a lot different to NRL.
So what we see in say Jesse Williams (great first name as it is the same name as my youngest son), he is showing excellent playing qualities but how this would translate to being a first grader of "superstar" quality, I don't know.
We had high opinions of Tyrell Sloan, Bud Sullivan and even Junior Amone, but I cannot see either of them (should Amone come back to NRL) being of superstar status with only Tyrell now at the Dragons.
Brett Morris to me was a genuine superstar from his early Dapto days to St George Illawarra NRL days. I hope that Jesse Williams can emulate him.