mattyg
Bench
- Messages
- 4,170
lockyno1 said:WTF, I would say O'Meley and Mason and Ryan were much more important than Sonny "I can't stay on the field" Bill Williams! Gosh rating him in the top 10 is a joke! Buderus, Webcke, Simpson, etc are all better players.
5 games this year, 1 test match. He has played 80 minutes in 4 first grade games and in the test match as well, and has not been injured. I'm not going to rate Buderus in the top 10, or simpson for that matter because Newcastle have yet again shown to me that when they dont have Johns they can't win. Perhaps my opinion will change and i wont rate SBW as highly this week if we lose to the sharks with Mason and O'Meley out..
And Ryan has not been better than SBW this year. Ryan was outstanding today and in the City/Country game but still i think sbw has done more, and O'Meley seems to drop the ball too much making simple hit ups.
I must say that i agree Webcke should get a mention in the best few players in the game, but i can't exactly fit 11 players into 10, and civo has been better for the broncos this year i think