What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Will Pucovski - How far will he go?

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
153,447
What’s wrong with Pelicans? Pretty awesome if you ask me


tenor.gif
 

TheParraboy

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
68,119
They are saying on Sports Sunday it is his 10th concussion

Fitzy reckons time to call it a day :rolleyes:

Tubby reckons he will be back
 
Messages
4,418
What do you guys reckon of Puck's career from here. Or does he have a career? Concussion is no fun thing to have recurring. But if the man himself feels he is fine to play then as one of the most promising cricketers in a generation not only do we accept that we have to encourage it. He is too good to lose.
 

jargan83

Coach
Messages
14,946
They are saying on Sports Sunday it is his 10th concussion

Fitzy reckons time to call it a day :rolleyes:

Tubby reckons he will be back

Edit: Didn't realize I'd posted this half baked post.

If Fitzy says it's time to call it a day he's probably got a 10 year career ahead of him.
 
Last edited:

Bazal

Post Whore
Messages
102,900
What do you guys reckon of Puck's career from here. Or does he have a career? Concussion is no fun thing to have recurring. But if the man himself feels he is fine to play then as one of the most promising cricketers in a generation not only do we accept that we have to encourage it. He is too good to lose.

He can stay in the nets with 86m of cotton wool wrapped around his head until he learns to play the short shit.

Wouldn't even have him in Shield RN let alone in contention for the test team. The kid is a walking coma candidate
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
153,001
very talented but physically he may never be able to handle test cricket
 

TheParraboy

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
68,119
Rule him out of the whole ashes might be the best thing for him mentally

Concentrate on Shield when he is ready




Will Pucovski set to miss start of Ashes as return delayed​

Victoria coach Chris Rogers has urged a cautious approach with the batter to ensure he has a long career ahead

Story Image



Will Pucovski is all-but ruled out of the start of the Ashes series after not recovering from his latest concussion in time for Victoria's next Sheffield Shield match and his state coach Chris Rogers has cautioned against rushing him back into the national set-up.

Pucovski was hit in the nets last month and suffered his 10th concussion dating back to a football injury when he was a teenager. After he missed the trip to Sydney last week it was hoped he would pull up for the return fixture at the MCG on Friday but symptoms are persisting and he has yet to bat again in the nets.

"It's no doubt a setback. I'd say now it's unlikely he will play in the first Test," Rogers said. "All the people in these conversations understand we have an immense talent on our hands. We want him playing in three, five, 10 years so these are the decisions we are going make in his best interests and hopefully we can set him up to have a long career."

He is now highly unlikely to be included in the large group of Australian players that will head to Queensland later this month to quarantine ahead of a intrasquad match that is set to decide final Ashes selection.

Pucovski made his Test debut against India at the SCG in January and that is the last competitive game he played due to a shoulder injury sustained in the match which required reconstructive surgery.


Although there remains hope he could feature in the yet-to-be-confirmed third Shield game between Victoria and New South Wales, the condensed nature of the Ashes schedule and his lack of cricket means it is increasingly likely he may not feature at all.

"No doubt there's a lot of frustration for him, he wants to be playing," Rogers said. "It's an interesting one as well, he hasn't played for seven [nine] months so to walk straight back into the caldron and perform against very good opposition that's going to be really difficult. The decision is to look after him and allow him a bit more time to prepare in the right way rather than rush him into matches that will have a lot of intensity and scrutiny.

"In this situation there's a strong desire to get him into that Australian side because he's such a talent player but...there's got to be some thought about what's in his best interest and how that plans out. He's still so young, there's so much time left in the game for him so no need to rush him back into a Test series when he hasn't even played professional cricket and isn't 100%."

Pucovski's absence would leave his Victoria team-mate Marcus Harris as the likely opening partner for David Warner at the Gabba - the same pairing that featured against India in January. Harris started his season with a second-innings century against New South Wales to follow his strong returns with Leicestershire.

Usman Khawaja, who has made two Shield hundreds this season, will also be in the frame but could be considered for a middle-order position with the No. 5 spot yet to be locked in. Travis Head has made a strong case with a productive start for South Australia and had previously been recalled for the postponed South Africa tour earlier this year having been dropped midway through the India series
 
Messages
4,418
Marcus Harris as the likely opening partner for David Warner at the Gabba - the same pairing that featured against India in January.
Prefer Us even tho he is no longer opening for the Bulls. He boasts a solid opening record in home Ashes. Harris has never played a home Ashes.

I am also hearing that should Tim Paine miss the First Test guess who they have as his replacement.. this blew me away.. Pete Nevill. Huge kick in the guts for Alex Carey.
 
Messages
4,418
Prefer Us even tho he is no longer opening for the Bulls. He boasts a solid opening record in home Ashes. Harris has never played a home Ashes.

I am also hearing that should Tim Paine miss the First Test guess who they have as his replacement.. this blew me away.. Pete Nevill. Huge kick in the guts for Alex Carey.
 

TheParraboy

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
68,119
I am also hearing that should Tim Paine miss the First Test guess who they have as his replacement.. this blew me away.. Pete Nevill. Huge kick in the guts for Alex Carey.

Not totally surprising for me, but would have preferred Carey, thinking long term

Back of my mind cant help thinking they have an eye towards the test series in India, and believe Nevill is the better and more experienced keeper to take there so play him in the ashes.
 
Messages
4,418
Not totally surprising for me, but would have preferred Carey, thinking long term

Back of my mind cant help thinking they have an eye towards the test series in India, and believe Nevill is the better and more experienced keeper to take there so play him in the ashes.
Yes that may be the reason as to only pick him this late in his career for a solitary match does not quite gel. The India series is still 12 months off so Carey will now have to wait yet another year before taking the national gloves. He is now 30. Dont make him wait too long.. tho fact is most of our recent past keepers got their first Test at about 30. Paine had to wait until he was 33 for his return.
 
Last edited:
Messages
4,418
Just looked up Nevill's away record. He has only played in the subcontinent once.. back in 2015/16 and it was not in India. Sri Lanka and he scored 52 @8.5.. took 10 catches and one stumping from three Tests. Hardly an earth shattering tour. On the other hand Paine has toured India.. 10 matches 561 @45 - 38 catches but no stumpings. He has also toured Sri Lanka and Pakistan.
 
Last edited:

AlwaysGreen

Post Whore
Messages
50,125
Just looked up Nevill's away record. He has only played in the subcontinent once.. back in 2015/16 and it was not in India. Sri Lanka and he scored 52 @8.5.. took 10 catches and one stumping from three Tests. Hardly an earth shattering tour.
So room for Red ball improvement then.
 

Latest posts

Top