What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

witt > moon

Drzoidberg

Juniors
Messages
1,135
Witt was really only a good goal kicker, why carry him just for that?? have i missed something? or is league turning into rugby where if you can kick goals your in, if so why not sign wilkinson or o'gara? who cares if they can play the game because they can kick haha
 

Rich102

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
11,903
Witt was really only a good goal kicker, why carry him just for that?? have i missed something? or is league turning into rugby where if you can kick goals your in, if so why not sign wilkinson or o'gara? who cares if they can play the game because they can kick haha

We carry Kemp soley as a goal kicker!
 

NZ Warrior

First Grade
Messages
6,444
More (WB)IHC propoganda!!!

Moon will become the Warriors' greatest ever 5/8. You will forget all about Gene Ngamu, Shane Endacott & John Simon.

Moon is the answer.
 

Rastafarian

Bench
Messages
2,959
you guys need a new goal kicker... Kemp is just hopeless, sorry to say. He could've won you guys the game last week IMHO. Well, would've could've should've....
 

Drzoidberg

Juniors
Messages
1,135
We carry Kemp soley as a goal kicker!

really when he misses so many? weird when others in the team can kick goals! understandable if no one else could kick goals but at least four players other than kemp have kicked goals in the past.
 
Last edited:

Lego_Man

First Grade
Messages
5,071
f**k me, right out of the WBIHC play book.

The truth is Moon sh*ts on Witt, particularly on defence. Witt was a turnstyle while Moon puts on solid hits and doesnt get driven back as Witt does.

Moon also has a far better running game and can break tackles.

Moon's general play kicking (long) is far superior.

Witt edges him in passing game.

Verdict = Moon wins.
 

wittyfan

Immortal
Messages
30,074
Well said nibbs.

Also Cleary and Hart need to go back to the drawing board if they think someone with a soccer background can possibly replace a 90% goalkicker.

Moon, apart from the first half against a poor Parramatta team in Round 1, has been terrible and has already been hooked once. And of course when he went off the Warriors were then able to beat the Roosters.

Deep down Cleary probably knows he's made a hugely bad judgement about Moon but it's all too late now.
 

MKEB...

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
5,989
Geez it taken 11 posts before WF jumped in.
Chalk that one to posterity folks, WF's crush must be subsiding.
 

Micistm

Bench
Messages
4,470
Lol, I'll reserve judgement at this very early stage. I want to see the team together for a few weeks without the mish mash of the injuries, and see how they go then
 

Rovelli

Bench
Messages
4,384
Moon hasn't been great, but can we say Witt would have done better? He would have kicked the goals, but would we have scored those tries?
 

nibbs

Bench
Messages
4,506
moon has done nothing that a 5/8 should. i haven't seen any dynamic cut out passes or majestic left/right foot steps bamboozling oppositions. i recall witt's fine pass against the storm that helped ropati get outside of folau. without that witt pass and then that incredible that unique ability to put himself in the right place at the right time, to take vatuvei's offload, we'd have lost that game i tell ya. plus witt is 90% goal kicker. f**k moon, man. we were better off with witt. he is more or less a carbon copy of ropati when he played 5/8. and we all know how that turned out.

reflecting on last week, and probably the knights game in round 5. potentially, 3 competition points better off we'd be. with witt kicking the goals, that is.
 
Last edited:

Redback71

First Grade
Messages
8,106
At least Witt would have won you the last couple of games with his goal kicking. By the way what did he do wrong you guys almost made the grandfinal with him at 5/8th.
 

Latest posts

Top