To me the situation in the 3 quarters looks pretty good. Not one person has listed robbo in their sides and yet it was widely agreed he was our best back for the first 6 or 8 rounds on the year. I say this not as a Robbo promotion, but an example of hte depth in our side.
for me our starting backline should be this;
1 shif
2 phil
3 mogg
4 frawley
5 gaf
6 j smith
7 mac
phil HAS to be there. Yes his defence is questionable and yes some games you forget his on the field, but he has an inane ability to score tries, which is something we need- especially now joel has left. Frawley is, to me at least, an unknown quantity in the centres but deserves a shot. Gaf is very important because his just so versatile, and when required to cover in the halves can be replaced by one of several very solid performers, robbo and n smith being the two most notable.
depth is going to be the key. its still not a star studded backline but those waiting in the wings are as strong as at any club, and when injuries occur as they no doubt will it shouldnt have too much of an adverse effect on the team.