Your Top 10

[PARRA_FAN]

1. Andrew Johns
2. Darren Lockyer
3. Nathan Hindmarsh
4. Shane Webcke
5. Danny Buderus
6. Craig Gower
7. Scott Prince
8. Anthony Minichello
9. Ben Kennedy
10. Trent Barrett

 

[Raider_69]

When fully fit and top form

1. Barge Arse
2. Jason Smith
3. Darren Lockyer
4. Nathen Hindmarsh
5. Mark Gasnier
6. Scott Prince
7. Danny Buderus
8. Ben Kennedy
9. Anothony Minichello
10. Sonny Bill Williams

Webcke, Marshall, Bailey (Luke), Bowen, Barrett and a host of others are unlucky

 

[El Diablo]

1. Johns
2. Hindmarsh
3. Lockyer
4. Marshall
5. Gasnier
6. Hodgson
7. T. Smith
8. Thurston
9. Buderus
10. Bowen

 

[JoeysWheelchair05]

1. Johns

2. Lockyer
3. Bowen
4. Webcke
5. Hindmarsh
6. Hodgson
7. Minichiello
8. Harrison
9. Gasnier
10. Marshall

 

[brook]

I'm suprised so many people have left out Webke - in my mind he's still a contender for best forward in the game let alone a top 10 players list.

I agree with Simon about Benji and Farah - both will establish themselves as one of the games absolute elite, I'm not so sure either are there yet.

 

[The Devil]

1. Johns
2. Minichiello
3. Kennedy
4. Hindmarsh
5. Lockyer
6. Barrett
7. Buderus
8. Gasnier
9. Webke
10. J. Smith

 

[ledzep]

in rough order:

Johns
Minichiello (only a fraction behind him)
Lockyer
Hindmarsh
Gasnier
Morley
Hodgson
Bailey
Wing
Thurston

 

[Bring back John Fifita]

Currently,

1. Andrew Johns
2. Benji Marshall
3. Trent Barrett
4. Nathan Hindmarsh
5. Mark Gasnier
6. Anthony Minichiello
7. Jonathon Thurston
8. Luke Bailey
9. Scott Prince
10. Darren Lockyer.

Didn't include SBW only because of absence in 2005.

 

[sooperdooper]

how can SBW be named in there.....

johns
jones
mini
hindy
barrett
marshall
kennedy
webke
lockyer
gower

 

[Robster]

1. Andrew Johns
2. Anthony Minichiello
3. Stacey Jones
4. Justin Murphy
5. Darren Lockyer
6. Sonny Bill Williams
7. Shane Webke
8. Benji Marshall
9. Mark Gasnier
10.Ruben Wiki

 

[slamminsam246]

How is SBW in the Top 10 FFS? Seriously, I think he's the most overrated player in the game. I know he had one magnificant year in 2004 and made some huge hits and scored a couple of tries, but he hasn't barely played a game this year. Sure, he's good talent and could be one of the best back rowers to play the game. But he IS NOT a top ten player.
To tell you the truth I think he will fold under the pressure and expectations of everyone.

 

[Big Pete]

1. Andrew Johns
2. Darren Lockyer
3. Nathan Hindmarsh
4. Anthony Minichello
5. Scott Prince
6. Mark Gasnier
7. Shane Webcke
8. Steve Price
9. Ben Kennedy
10. Jason Smith

 

[melon....]

1. Minichiello - The boot fits
2. Fielden
3. Morley
4. McGuire - will be better than Johns and Lockyer put together
5. Johns
6. Toops - wouldnt swap him for any other young forward in the game
7. Webke - Still up there
8. Wing
9. Hidmarsh
10. Lockyer - if he stays fit.

 

[Balmain_Boy]

Wing? Hahahahaha

 

[Smartman]

1. Minichiello - The boot fits
2. Fielden
3. Morley
4. McGuire - will be better than Johns and Lockyer put together
5. Johns
6. Toops - wouldnt swap him for any other young forward in the game
7. Webke - Still up there
8. Wing
9. Hidmarsh
10. Lockyer - if he stays fit.

You havent included enough Rooter players :roll:

 

[FIREUPGAZ]

1. Barrett

 

[tiger_nick]

1. Minichiello - The boot fits
2. Fielden
3. Morley
4. McGuire - will be better than Johns and Lockyer put together
5. Johns
6. Toops - wouldnt swap him for any other young forward in the game
7. Webke - Still up there
8. Wing
9. Hidmarsh
10. Lockyer - if he stays fit.

Wow must be a pretty pathetic club that has four of the worlds best 10 players but can't even make the finals in the NRL

 

[ledzep]

Wing? Hahahahaha

i fail to see what's so funny
when wing is fit and in form, there's hardly a better player in the comp
he's also incredibly versatile, winning a premiership at halfback, playing rep at hooker, and also winning a man of the match award whilst playing in the centres for australia

 

[Kangaroo2]

For the year 2005

1. Andrew Johns
2. Jonathon Thurston
3. Scott Prince
4. Luke Bailey
5. Benji Marshall
6. Mark Gasnier
7. Trent Barrett
8. Brett Hodgeson
9. Braith Anasta
10. Darren Lockyer

 

[blackfriday]

in no particular and for not neccesarily last season:

andrew johns
darren lockyer
shane webcke
mark o'meley
ben kennedy
nathan hindmarsh
trent barrett
steve price
mark gasnier
anthony minichiello