What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

NRL Worst 17

Packy

Bench
Messages
4,243
Yeah...may want to try again. :lol:

Hodgo was a key element of the Broncos success that season and did a great job creating a roll on for the squad.

The only candidates for that team would be Stagg, Perry, Carlaw and McGuire.

Perry as a second-string halfback is a gimme. Seymour was the Broncos most talented halfback, but poor form on and off the field cost him. Perry wasn't a star by any means, but he shored up the left edge defensively and his long distance kicking game was surprisingly effective finding the in-goal and staying there more often than not. To his credit as well, Shane had his best game for the Broncos in the Grand Final.

Stagg did a job for his team and allowed Bennett to run with Berro at hooker. He was solid but in a litany of great players he's probably worth a shout.

Both Dane and Casey were solid contributors off the bench but weren't anything special by 2006. To McGuire's credit, he did throw the hail mary which set up the Tate try in the corner. Whether you put it down to his pass or the support play is another matter entirely.

Rudder has a mortgage on the six, but if we're basing it on actual performances than it's difficult to look past Anasta. Braith played injured in the 2004 grand final and it clearly showed. He had a shocker and had to come off the field mid-way through the game. Thinking back on it, JT doesn't get the credit he deserves. He looked far better than Braith out there and came up with some great plays at the death. A lot of people consider him the token passenger, but for a bench utility he contributed more than most.

Yeah he was answering the question above his post.
 

Big Pete

Referee
Messages
29,023
Yeah he was answering the question above his post.

"Dragons footy"?

How far above we talking here?

should of been clive churchill medallist in 2000.

Such a myth.

Lockyer did it all for his team across the 80. Handled the kicking, set up tries, was a constant threat on kick returns, saved tries etc.

But because Phillips was called onto make more customary fullback tackles suddenly he's the hard-luck story.

There were maybe one or two try-savers that were worth celebrating, the rest if he had have missed him, serious questions would have been asked.
 
Messages
4,370
Such a myth.

Lockyer did it all for his team across the 80. Handled the kicking, set up tries, was a constant threat on kick returns, saved tries etc.

But because Phillips was called onto make more customary fullback tackles suddenly he's the hard-luck story.

There were maybe one or two try-savers that were worth celebrating, the rest if he had have missed him, serious questions would have been asked.
Even when the horses win the grand final their fans are still salty.
 

Shaun Hewitt

First Grade
Messages
6,377
On current form, Ayshford wouldn't be anywhere near as the worst.
Might not be a superstar, but no means the worst there is
 

coolumsharkie

Referee
Messages
26,848
Matt Prior has been excellent this year and was very good last year. He's keeping David Fafita out of a spot.
 

Lambretta

First Grade
Messages
8,685
What about a worst team of premiership winning players? Only from the nrl era

1. Phillips
2. C. Smith
3. Linett
4. Hegarty
5. Fitzhenry
6. Rudder
7. Perry
8. Tyrell
9. Perry
10. Howe
11. Marquet
12. O'neill
13. Lowrie

14. D. Williams (storm)
15. Mauro
16. Hughes
17. Saffy

Some of these guys aren't that bad, like luke Phillips for example, but most other premiership fullbacks are stars. Only starting players in their grand final positions in the starting 13 and bench players for the bench obviously.

Wash your mouth out - Luke Phillips was one of my favourite players of all time. Such f**king bravery and a talent for sure

If there was a team for worst self preservation of all time he'd be in it. The guy had a death wish at times :lol:

But yeah - full back is hard because so many guns play there. It's hard to win a comp without a gun fullback.

Luke Patten is probably the other choice, but the General was brilliant at times and I respected him as a player who used his brains to make up for deficiencies in his natural abilities. Players who play above their natural ability get more respect from me because they earn every second they play.

As for the person who said Robbie Ross - give yourself an upper cut. Brilliant player.
 

9701

First Grade
Messages
5,400
lol you idiot. We've lost two games this year, one by 4 points against the eels who were good, while our whole team was shit, and one by 1 point against the broncos that we should've won.

please point our when we've "turned to mud".

1995-2004, 2006-2014 :)
 

Lambretta

First Grade
Messages
8,685
Such a myth.

Lockyer did it all for his team across the 80. Handled the kicking, set up tries, was a constant threat on kick returns, saved tries etc.

But because Phillips was called onto make more customary fullback tackles suddenly he's the hard-luck story.

There were maybe one or two try-savers that were worth celebrating, the rest if he had have missed him, serious questions would have been asked.

It's not a myth Pete - he was brilliant that day

Lockyer was great too and influencing the win probably gave him the vote on the day, but I still maintain Phillips played the better game. Probably because we did more defending so he was actually involved more.

In short, he did more because he had to. Lockyer, great as he was, had the luxury of needing to do less. But it was bloody close.

Respect goes to both players that day.
 

DiegoNT

First Grade
Messages
9,378
Wash your mouth out - Luke Phillips was one of my favourite players of all time. Such f**king bravery and a talent for sure

If there was a team for worst self preservation of all time he'd be in it. The guy had a death wish at times :lol:

But yeah - full back is hard because so many guns play there. It's hard to win a comp without a gun fullback.

Luke Patten is probably the other choice, but the General was brilliant at times and I respected him as a player who used his brains to make up for deficiencies in his natural abilities. Players who play above their natural ability get more respect from me because they earn every second they play.

As for the person who said Robbie Ross - give yourself an upper cut. Brilliant player.

So who is the worst premiership winning fullbacks of the nrl era then? Though worst isn't the best word when describing it considering the quality of all the fullbacks eligible. Maybe least best?
 
Top