Titans about to name a PROVEN rookie coach....while we are stuck with our own rookie in Mary

[ouryear]

Garth Brennan, Panthers cup coach.

Great selection.
To be announced soon.

Just shows, it doesn't have to be boring Madge or mad Hasler, though Madge may be well suited to become the Blues SOO coach.

Brennan has served a long and very successful apprenticeship, similar to JD.

Titans got it right!

 

[Old Kogarah Boy 1]

Garth Brennan, Panthers cup coach.

Great selection.
To be announced soon.

Just shows, it doesn't have to be boring Madge or mad Hasler.

Titans got it right!

So let me get this straight, the Titans are about to sign up a rookie coach.
Nice.
We have a rookie coach.

 

[Life's Good]

That will keep Madge & Hasler on ice, waiting for someone to get the bullet.

 

[ouryear]

So let me get this straight, the Titans are about to sign up a rookie coach.
Nice.
We have a rookie coach.

Ahhh...but A rookie coach who has proven himself....a rookie who has won decent comps....not just a local comp like Mary did.

A rookie coach who talks and analyses games like he knows what he is doing.

A rookie coach wit runs on the board.

A smart coach.

And a coach who beat many other coaches to the role.

Mary had to beat no one....it was handed to him.

Can you name one great coach who was never once a rookie coach?

Mary is no rookie.....he is ####

 

[Saintsified]

3 out of our last 4 coaches were rookies. Brown, Price and Mary, we have shown everyone how its done, Titans have got nothing on us when it comes to rookies.

 

[ouryear]

3 out of our last 4 coaches were rookies. Brown, Price and Mary, we have shown everyone how its done, Titans have got nothing on us when it comes to rookies.

I think the major difference is Garth Brennan has served his apprenticeship and won some very competitive comps....aka JD when he was with.us....who many on this forum want.

Brown, Price and Mary never won a meat raffle...let alone competitions.

 

[ouryear]

That will keep Madge & Hasler on ice, waiting for someone to get the bullet.

I really don't think any club is interested in boring and stodgy coaches.

Everyone wants a coach with.ideas and vision.

Des and Madge will be lucky to coach again too soon.....although Madge is up for SOO coach

 

[Life's Good]

I really don't think any club is interested in boring and stodgy coaches.

Everyone wants a coach with.ideas and vision.

Des and Madge will be lucky to coach again too soon.....although Madge is up for SOO coach

Boring, stodgy & Premiership winning coaches trump boring & stodgy imposters every day of the week. Just sayin...

 

[ouryear]

Boring, stodgy & Premiership winning coaches trump boring & stodgy imposters every day of the week. Just sayin...

When they won the premiership, they weren't boring and stodgy.

Manly and souths both played exciting footy.

But like players, some coaches have use by dates and lose form.

Losing form like Isaac Luke, Tuiveshek, Aaron Woods, etc.

I would not want Hasler or Madge, they have become boring coaches as time has go on.

Madge has been out of form for 3 yrs and Des is going slowly insane.

 

[Life's Good]

When they won their flags, they certainly weren't boring and stodgy.
Manly and soufs both played exciting footy.

But like players, some coaches have use by dates and lose form.

Isaac Luke, TVS, Woods. And Coaches Hasler and Madge.....I would not want them.

Madge has been out of form for 3 yrs and Des is going slowly insane.

What’s with the ‘flag’? That’s a fumble ball term.

 

[nontime111]

sign JD now Doust!

Stop the rot

 

[Saint_JimmyG]

Garth Brennan, Panthers cup coach.

Great selection.
To be announced soon.

Just shows, it doesn't have to be boring Madge or mad Hasler, though Madge may be well suited to become the Blues SOO coach.

Brennan has served a long and very successful apprenticeship, similar to JD.

Titans got it right!

Ironically, so did Steve Price.

Saints cannot afford another rookie coach such as Demetriou.

 

[ouryear]

Ironically, so did Steve Price.

Saints cannot afford another rookie coach such as Demetriou.

You sure Jimmy?....did price have 5 or more years under various very high performing coaches, and then take a nsw cup team to a premiership and interstate championship winner?

Also, Brennan was up against 5 or so very high quality other applicants. A grinding interview process.

I think price was just handed the job.

Titans have been thorough.

 

[Dennis Papaioannou]

Ironically, so did Steve Price.

Saints cannot afford another rookie coach such as Demetriou.

You're probably right because that would be 3 in a row.
Demetriou would have been a logic choice instead of McGregor but we let that chance slip by and we are now paying for it.
A 3rd rookie failure would just compound the situation even though I think Demetriou is classes above McGregor.

 

[Saint_JimmyG]

You sure Jimmy?....did price have 5 or more years under various very high performing coaches, and then take a nsw cup team to a premiership and interstate championship winner?

Also, Brennan was up against 5 or so very high quality other applicants. A grinding interview process.

I think price was just handed the job.

Titans have been thorough.

Price served a long apprenticeship under both Bennett and Browm which reached its apogee with the 2005 Jersey Flegg premiership.

Under his tutelage, the likes of the Morris twins, Merrin and Nightingale all became first graders.

And while he wasn't able win another title, his sides''usually did very well.

 

[JDHD]

You sure Jimmy?....did price have 5 or more years under various very high performing coaches, and then take a nsw cup team to a premiership and interstate championship winner?

Also, Brennan was up against 5 or so very high quality other applicants. A grinding interview process.

I think price was just handed the job.

Titans have been thorough.

We should not discount the fact that Gordon 'Absolute Potato' Tallis was one of the three people on the selection committee. That guy has the judgement of a toddler.

 

[RedV Resurgence]

When does someone stop being a rookie coach? How much longer are we going to categories McGregor as a rookie?

In my mind, whilst he is a rookie coach, he needs to be shielded from the demands of success. Surely, he is now beyond the Rookie stage and his teams performances must represent this value.

Further, didn't he state last year that he had the team he wanted? we didn't make the semi-finals and didn't have a bad run of injuries.

 

[Dennis Papaioannou]

When does someone stop being a rookie coach? How much longer are we going to categories McGregor as a rookie?

In my mind, whilst he is a rookie coach, he needs to be shielded from the demands of success. Surely, he is now beyond the Rookie stage and his teams performances must represent this value.

Further, didn't he state last year that he had the team he wanted? we didn't make the semi-finals and didn't have a bad run of injuries.

In McGregor's case he is unqualified to coach FG.
There is a difference that cannot be changed by time at the helm.

 

[Overseas dragon]

l i for one cant believe we had a ferrari sitting in the garage JASON D .so what happened we gave it to mary on his jetski wow the incompetance is just overwhelming .go the old boys club

 

[Outlaw Pete]

McGregor is no longer a rookie coach. just a totally inept one.
Doust and the Board are also inept as well as self serving. some MUST know McGregor is incompetent but propose to do nothing about it. How the bloody hell could they reappoint the goose back in April.