Which RL player from the ghosts of Christmas past would you like to see return?

[Nice Beaver]

The usual contribution to a healthy forum from you

No more than you with your throwing Melbourne and Bellamy into every thread under the sun.

 

[POPEYE]

No more than you with your throwing Melbourne and Bellamy into every thread under the sun.

Still haven't recovered from my 'likeable pussy' of years ago . . . what forum was that in, not LU from memory

 

[Nice Beaver]

Still haven't recovered from my 'likeable pussy' of years ago . . . what forum was that in, not LU from memory

WTF are you on about??

 

[hineyrulz]

Paul Carige circa 1998 would be good for a laugh.

:lol: f**k off you merkin.


Tim Smith before he lost the plot circa 2005.

 

[The Pelican]

Purely from a Roosters perspective

1. Mini - 03-05
2. Freddy - All of his time with us.
3. Morley - Same as Freddy

 

[sharknows]

Sharks - Gavin Miller

 

[carlosthedwarf]

Similar to McKinnon - Tuiaki and Dwyer.

I want to see Mateo back to his final Eels season form. Biggest mistake the club made was letting him go.

 

[POPEYE]

WTF are you on about??

Supposed you have noticed that I don't make a habit of following people on the forum just to ridicule them, that's just 'too f**king easy'. I never instigate anything vitriolic but that doesn't mean if you want to declare a verbal war I'm not up for it. By the way, I talk about all teams and coaches, I'm also a big fan of Toovey and Manly . . . and I do like a slice of well cooked pussy

 

[Still Nutty]

Geez...the list could be long.

Geoff Robinson for the Dogs the MoiMoi of the 80's - I was a Parra supporter back then and used to go to Belmore to watch the clashes. Hated the Dogs with a passion but always loved seeing him come on off the bench.

Eric Grothe Snr in the early to mid 80s - most damaging ball running winger I've ever seen - his try from a line drop out against the Bulldogs in a semi final is still up there in the top 5 of all time individual tries

Ben Kennedy - for his time at the Knights but more so for his games in Origin for the Blues

Brett Kenny - played juniors with him at Guildford leagues (many MANY years ago) probably the most naturally gifted running and attacking 5/8 I have ever seen.

Cliffy Lyons across any period - struck match between him and Bert for skill and ability

I'm sure there are plenty more like Bradley Clyde, Steve Rogers, etc, etc. like I said, the list could go on and on...

But without doubt No. 1 is Alex McKinnon as the Baron said.

 

[Shaun Hewitt]

In their prime:

From the Warriors; Paleaasina, Lautiti, Faafili, Ngamu, Hoppe, Campion and Villasanti

From other teams: Sailor, Nathan Brown, El Masri, Willie Mason (either the 'fro or the braids), O'Meley, Daley, Joey, Alfie, Blacklock, Preston Campbell, Steve Reardon

 

[Shaun Hewitt]

ooh and Matty Bowen and Matty Sing

 

[Nice Beaver]

Supposed you have noticed that I don't make a habit of following people on the forum just to ridicule them, that's just 'too f**king easy'. I never instigate anything vitriolic but that doesn't mean if you want to declare a verbal war I'm not up for it. By the way, I talk about all teams and coaches, I'm also a big fan of Toovey and Manly . . . and I do like a slice of well cooked pussy

How that answers the question as to what you are on about I have no idea.

Regardless, no I don't notice your habits and movements on the forums. Hate to rock your world but I could care less. Just making an observation that you tend to bring the Storm and Bellamy into most conversations.

Congrats on your eating habits.

 

[Still Nutty]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F_6loPG0TCw

Re my earlier post, it mustn't have been a drop out for this particular try but still stands the test of time.

Edit - should have put this link in too...appreciate and enjoy

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jAGQMnq9E4g

 

[POPEYE]

How would the Broncos like to have just Wally Lewis in the current mix, the Dogs Terry Lamb, Joey at the Knights . . . many single additions of past players would make the difference

 

[Burwood]

MacDougall in 2000. Was unstoppable playing fullback. Uate when he first burst onto the scene- was raw, but very dangerous and played with no fear

And Blacklock when he sustained form back in 98-01. Loved watching his ability to pop up anywhere on the field and score a long range try.

 

[POPEYE]

How that answers the question as to what you are on about I have no idea.

Regardless, no I don't notice your habits and movements on the forums. Hate to rock your world but I could care less. Just making an observation that you tend to bring the Storm and Bellamy into most conversations.

Congrats on your eating habits.

So what, you don't want to punch on or even discuss a subject, just snipe. Thank your lucky stars I don't give a f**k about your habits or movements

 

[eozsmiles]

How would the Broncos like to have just Wally Lewis in the current mix, the Dogs Terry Lamb, Joey at the Knights . . . many single additions of past players would make the difference

They would like it very much. Any club that didn't appreciate the reincarnation of a former great to strengthen their playing squad would be a bit silly.

 

[eozsmiles]

I wouldn't mind seeing the original "big three" come back and have a crack - Changa, Puff, and Chook. I'm not old enough to have seen them play and they are immortals. I'm sure it would be a thrill.

 

[POPEYE]

They would like it very much. Any club that didn't appreciate the reincarnation of a former great to strengthen their playing squad would be a bit silly.

I didn't mean it quite that way, more as a guide to what type of single player is needed, but yes they would be silly wouldn't they

 

[Still Nutty]

Forgot to include Artie Beetson in there! Absolute legend for the Roosters and Eels.

Never saw him play but would love to have seen Clive Churchill play - there isn't much footage of him around but the stats and the first hand accolades from those that did suggest he would be great in any era