Vic Mackey
Referee
- Messages
- 24,589
Napa, Scott and Elliot would all be horrible signings
Napa wasnt wanted by the team who won 3 games all year
Scott has huge off field problems and has been let go by the best club of the last 20 years and a side who has played a GF and prelim recently but yes, our culture will turn him around. Id rather keep Jet, seriously
Elliot is just bog average and again off field issues. Id rather give Blore and Tuilagi a chance to establish themselves over him
Ash Taylor is an interesting one. In your squad of 30 you need 4 halves. We have Brooks, Doueihi, Madden and Hastings. Doueihi will miss the first 4-8 weeks and apparently Hastings is being looked at as a utility. I actually dont mind it. He has a great kicking game, gets a lot of set restarts which is Brooks weakest point. A 1 year deal on smallish money and he isnt a bad get IMO
Napa wasnt wanted by the team who won 3 games all year
Scott has huge off field problems and has been let go by the best club of the last 20 years and a side who has played a GF and prelim recently but yes, our culture will turn him around. Id rather keep Jet, seriously
Elliot is just bog average and again off field issues. Id rather give Blore and Tuilagi a chance to establish themselves over him
Ash Taylor is an interesting one. In your squad of 30 you need 4 halves. We have Brooks, Doueihi, Madden and Hastings. Doueihi will miss the first 4-8 weeks and apparently Hastings is being looked at as a utility. I actually dont mind it. He has a great kicking game, gets a lot of set restarts which is Brooks weakest point. A 1 year deal on smallish money and he isnt a bad get IMO