What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

2025 Origin 3 - Wed 9 Jul - NSW 12-24 QLD @ Accor

Who wins?


  • Total voters
    20
  • Poll closed .

Artiste

Bench
Messages
4,462
I could not give a flying "F" who you pick at fullback, just don't ever pick this imbecile edwards again.
An absolute dud at rep level and even at club level been ordinary this year.
I don't care what he does in the 2nd half, he has not been close to deserving to play SOO, what a waste of space
Said this all along, he’s a dud
 

aqua_duck

Coach
Messages
18,763
Cleary is a great club half back but in my mind where Moses is superior is that Moses performs better in chaos and plays what’s in front of him a lot more. Cleary is so methodical and abit of a perfectionist in many regards that he’s struggling to adapt to what’s happening around him both in regards to Qld’s line speed and the general execution.
Compare how Cleary is playing to Munster and it’s literally night and day, Munster is keeping the defence guessing, playing what’s in front of him and being an absolute menace out there. Cleary is going through the motions and not executing
 
Messages
3,597
Tbh he has picked an absolutely terrible side though? Weird take.

Robson over Api
Max King over any other NSW middle forward
The entire bench
Robson has been decent so far. I'd go Api too but they're not getting flogged because of Robson mate. The 3/4 line alone is elite and proven at this level. It's far from a terrible side but there's a lot of good players playing terribly. Absolutely deserve a hiding.
 

aqua_duck

Coach
Messages
18,763
Amazing considering how many of them play(ed) in the same Penrith team.
I think there in lies half the issue. That Penrith combo is like a finely tuned performance car and has become so methodical and well oiled that the engine doesn’t run if there’s even one part that’s a little loose or if the road is abit bumpy.
 

Bazal

Post Whore
Messages
106,547
He was absolute dogshit the first 6 years of his career. Maybe normal order has resumed?

He's killing it for Parra still.

I can only assume Loz has bored him half into a coma like the rest of them.

In all seriousness though he's a winger. Probably the hardest position to make a game changing impact from in a side playing shit. To'o has been pretty anonymous too and he's the second best winger of the NRL era. Lolmax just has the derp moments on top
 

Bazal

Post Whore
Messages
106,547
Robson has been decent so far. I'd go Api too but they're not getting flogged because of Robson mate. The 3/4 line alone is elite and proven at this level. It's far from a terrible side but there's a lot of good players playing terribly. Absolutely deserve a hiding.

Robson has been the second worst on ground this game?

His attack is absolutely pedestrian, he's a huge part of the reason the epic 3/4 line isn't firing.
 

mongoose

Coach
Messages
12,486
Cleary is a great club half back but in my mind where Moses is superior is that Moses performs better in chaos and plays what’s in front of him a lot more. Cleary is so methodical and abit of a perfectionist in many regards that he’s struggling to adapt to what’s happening around him both in regards to Qld’s line speed and the general execution.
Compare how Cleary is playing to Munster and it’s literally night and day, Munster is keeping the defence guessing, playing what’s in front of him and being an absolute menace out there. Cleary is going through the motions and not executing
which is strange cause he played the most brilliant chaotic 20-30 min in a grand final ever in 2023
 
Top