Ref and Bunker Decisions

[The Axe of Druss]

And I'm asking if there is another example of that particular ruling.

You don't have one, just admit it

Why would I you dope. Im referring to all rule interpretations

 

[Valheru]

Why would I you dope. Im referring to all rule interpretations

Because that's what I was asking about when you decided to butt in.

Concession noted

 

[yobbo84]

There were 3 blatant incidents of foul play just ignored by the bunker in 3 separate matches - on Keppie (high tackle across throat), Fermor (high tackle across face) and Walsh (hit late). Two of those incidents led directly to tries being scored the next set by their opponents.

The number of times the refs change interpretations in the same season just adds another layer of imbalance to the competition.

 

[Captain Apollo]

The funniest part of this is Easts fans thinking they still support a big relevant club.

The even funnier part.... Panthers fans thinking we give a crap what they think about our club

 

[gerg]

There were 3 blatant incidents of foul play just ignored by the bunker in 3 separate matches - on Keppie (high tackle across throat), Fermor (high tackle across face) and Walsh (hit late). Two of those incidents led directly to tries being scored the next set by their opponents.

The number of times the refs change interpretations in the same season just adds another layer of imbalance to the competition.

Another I noticed - and at the risk of upsetting Valheru and the Roosters brigade - how about that magnificent tackle from Tedesco to deny Tuilaga a try yesterday afternoon. Marvellous covering tackle where even the commentators missed the very clear swinging arm to the head.

 

[Old Mate]

Another I noticed - and at the risk of upsetting Valheru and the Roosters brigade - how about that magnificent tackle from Tedesco to deny Tuilaga a try yesterday afternoon. Marvellous covering tackle where even the commentators missed the very clear swinging arm to the head.

Yes indeed, was like the commentators were watching something else entirely

 

[The Axe of Druss]

Because that's what I was asking about when you decided to butt in.

Concession noted

Its called conversation bud but hey, you keep jibbering to no one then

 

[Captain Apollo]

Another I noticed - and at the risk of upsetting Valheru and the Roosters brigade - how about that magnificent tackle from Tedesco to deny Tuilaga a try yesterday afternoon. Marvellous covering tackle where even the commentators missed the very clear swinging arm to the head.

Yes, and Tulilaga suffered a significant injury from it and will miss upwards of 6 weeks... oh, wait

 

[gerg]

Yes, and Tulilaga suffered a significant injury from it and will miss upwards of 6 weeks... oh, wait

I wasn't aware that an incident and subsequent injury had such a bearing on whether a player is suspended, put on report, penalised or isnt even noticed. Thanks for the clarification.

 

[Captain Apollo]

I wasn't aware that an incident and subsequent injury had such a bearing on whether a player is suspended, put on report, penalised or isnt even noticed. Thanks for the clarification.

The NRL have said publicly a few seasons back that any resulting injury from foul play will affect the grading of any charge on a player who committed said act.

 

[gerg]

The NRL have said publicly a few seasons back that any resulting injury from foul play will affect the grading of any charge on a player who committed said act.

Ok. Onfield referee and bunker didn't even look at it, despite it being; high, moderate force, direct to the head and in the act of scoring a try. It's on the video highlights of the game on the NRL site and it's pretty clear that all of those criteria were involved. But not even a penalty, so its hard to be charged? At the start of the year that is probably a sinbin. Also at the start of the year the NRL were actively discouraging 'milking'. If Tuilagi stays down he probably draws attention to the incident. But rely who knows at this point.
Is there a way to bookmark this exchange for when Tedesco ducks into a high tackle?

 

[Captain Apollo]

Ok. Onfield referee and bunker didn't even look at it, despite it being; high, moderate force, direct to the head and in the act of scoring a try. It's on the video highlights of the game on the NRL site and it's pretty clear that all of those criteria were involved. But not even a penalty, so its hard to be charged? At the start of the year that is probably a sinbin. Also at the start of the year the NRL were actively discouraging 'milking'. If Tuilagi stays down he probably draws attention to the incident. But rely who knows at this point.
Is there a way to bookmark this exchange for when Tedesco ducks into a high tackle?

Yes, I'm sure that Siua Wong will really give a damn whilst he recovers from the MCL injury he suffered due to the cannonball tackle committed by Karl Lawton. You know, the tackle the match officials and the bunker thought was an okay tackle and no foul play involved, yet one the MRC charged him with and to which Lawtwon plead guilty

 

[MKCS]

Of what? Favoured clubs getting good calls over the non-favoured ones? Comon man, dont be naive

I think the Roosters have been in the top 3 most penalised teams from 2018 through to 2024, we're definitely not favoured.

The funniest part of this is Easts fans thinking they still support a big relevant club.

Arguing otherwise would just be dishonest. Like it or not the Roosters are one of the most successful teams in the NRL era, they are in one of the most desirable and important markets (Sydney City), they have significant power when it comes to attracting players and staff and they've had very few poor seasons in the NRL era.

 

[Valheru]

2 perplexing decisions from the bunker in the games tonight.

Have they changed the knock on rule without telling us?

The warriors challenge that they were successful with was a clear knock on, it hit the warriors player than the Roosters player immediately after and they somehow called it a knock back.

The Penrith one where they challenged and he clean dropped it in the tackle was equally as bizarre.

I get it, no one is going to feel sorry for either team and both were well beaten but if thats the standard, we are going to have some controversial results.

 

[ColdWetPanther]

2 perplexing decisions from the bunker in the games tonight.

Have they changed the knock on rule without telling us?

The warriors challenge that they were successful with was a clear knock on, it hit the warriors player than the Roosters player immediately after and they somehow called it a knock back.

The Penrith one where they challenged and he clean dropped it in the tackle was equally as bizarre.

I get it, no one is going to feel sorry for either team and both were well beaten but if thats the standard, we are going to have some controversial results.

Please never change. There is something weirdly comforting about how predictable you are…

 

[Nuke]

I didn't see the first game tonight, and I was watching the Brisbane-Penrith game on my phone while at work, but even on that little screen, that Penrith 'no knock-on' decision deadset looked like Jenkins knocked-on.

Now, I hate the Broncs as much as anyone and will celebrate anything and everything that goes against them, but even I saw that one and was perplexed. And it's been a LONG time since I heard an entire stadium loudly and clearly get the "BULL..S**T! BULL..S**T!" chant going. I did enjoy that, and frankly, I didn't disagree with them.

 

[Wizardman]

f**k, I am tired with people blaming the ref for their teams shitness.

 

[Black Panther]

At least neither game last night was decided by the Refs. Maybe some ordinary calls, but the teams won the games.

 

[Nealo 12]

I didn't see the first game tonight, and I was watching the Brisbane-Penrith game on my phone while at work, but even on that little screen, that Penrith 'no knock-on' decision deadset looked like Jenkins knocked-on.

Now, I hate the Broncs as much as anyone and will celebrate anything and everything that goes against them, but even I saw that one and was perplexed. And it's been a LONG time since I heard an entire stadium loudly and clearly get the "BULL..S**T! BULL..S**T!" chant going. I did enjoy that, and frankly, I didn't disagree with them.

Maybe the old usual call of "Penalty Broncos " has seen its day ?

 

[T-Boon]

f**k, I am tired with people blaming the ref for their teams shitness.

Couldn't agree more.
My only issue with refereeing is their interpretation of a knock-on (the have knock on derangement syndrome). In particular I cannot get the decision that was made by the video referee that led to the Eels losing their review.