Who has the best 1,6,7,9?

[Crippler]

Calling Bears Fans

is this your best lineup?

1. Seers
6. Florimo
7. Taylor
9. Soden

 

[Moffo]

ikin > soden

 

[SuperSoward]

Culburra Dolphins For Sure

1. Luke Palcer
6. Garret Roberts/ Ryan Anderson
7. Jason Clay
9. Kurt Rundle

:thumn:thumn:thumn

 

[Loudstrat]

Barrett and Kimmorley have the runs on the board, simple as that. They have had solid rep careers and are hugely experienced. I could rely on them to at the very least play their role in organising the team from halfback as and be comfortable under pressure they have proven themselves at rep level before and that's good enough for me. I cannot say the same for Orford, though. His club form is probably as good as any NSW halfback but IMO he has simply not showed anything to suggest that he can handle Origin.

That argument is relevent 5 years ago.

Funny how winning Dally M POTY and a premiership in 4 weeks isn't good enough for Origin.

1. Mullins
6. Daley
7. Stuart
9. Walters

Thats the spine from god right there. That was also the spine for the 94 kangaroo tour. And to make it even more formidable add 13. Brad Clyde.

Pfft.

1) Taylor
6) Kenny
7) Sterling
9) Edge

with Price at 13 feeding Cronin, Ella and Grothe.

 

[watatank]

That argument is relevent 5 years ago.

Funny how winning Dally M POTY and a premiership in 4 weeks isn't good enough for Origin.

Nope, it's a great achievement to win those awards but IMO none of his performances, even the awards don't dispell the perception that he cracks under pressure, simply because he hasn't been placed under said pressure in winning them. It proves he is a good club player, which we already knew.

 

[Loudstrat]

Nope, it's a great achievement to win those awards but IMO none of his performances, even the awards don't dispell the perception that he cracks under pressure, simply because he hasn't been placed under said pressure in winning them. It proves he is a good club player, which we already knew.

And that is different from the rest of the NSW squad -how?

 

[Non Terminator]

Pfft.

1) Taylor
6) Kenny
7) Sterling
9) Edge

with Price at 13 feeding Cronin, Ella and Grothe.

Wouldn't mind seeing some of the other classics, or a franchise's best players into a 1,6,7,9 combo.

Here's a good one:

1. Darren LOCKYER
6. Wally LEWIS
7. Allan LANGER
9. Kerrod WALTERS

 

[watatank]

And that is different from the rest of the NSW squad -how?

Valid question if you assumed that I agreed with the rest of the selections in the NSW team, but I don't.

 

[Biscuits]

Wouldn't mind seeing some of the other classics, or a franchise's best players into a 1,6,7,9 combo.

Here's a good one:

1. Darren LOCKYER
6. Wally LEWIS
7. Allan LANGER
9. Kerrod WALTERS

eadie
thompson
gibbs
krillich


ridge
lyons
toovey
serdaris
thats a tough one to go past

 

[dubopov]

As I stated much earlier .. THIS is the best in my lifetime ..

1. Graeme Langlands
6. Poppa Clay
7. Billy Smith
12. Ian Walsh

.. and to the Parra bloke who included a lock ..

8. Johnny Raper

 

[bubblesunlimited]

1.Morvin Edwards
6.David Bayssari
7.Peter Camroux
9.Michael Brown

Too easy

 

[Joker's Wild]

Wouldn't mind seeing some of the other classics, or a franchise's best players into a 1,6,7,9 combo.

Here's a good one:

1. Darren LOCKYER
6. Wally LEWIS
7. Allan LANGER
9. Kerrod WALTERS

I raise you a:

1. Robbie O'Davis
6. Matt Johns
7. Andrew Johns
9. Danny Buderus

 

[Raider_69]

As others before me have mentioned, the halves, hookers and backs are not worth a pinch of sh*t unless you're pack is giving them the room and field position to get chances

with canberra's pack next year, which is not only one of the best but has the best depth, so long as our halves are in any way decent we'll be in for a good year. If Herbert stays fit and Campo continues on from last year, we're fair dinkum contenders. Our pack if fully fit, will not get beaten by any pack in the comp, its too big, too strong, its got balance with mobility and work rate aswell.

FTR: i think Melbourne, Manly and Broncos have the best spines... Penrith, Canberra and the Knights have the spines that are probably not rated but if they click, can become a really good unit.

 

[Raider_69]

I raise you a:

1. Robbie O'Davis
6. Matt Johns
7. Andrew Johns
9. Danny Buderus

LOL!!!!

1. Mullins/Badge
6. Daley
7. Stuart
9. Walters

Game. Set. Match.
Thank you lines men, thank you ball boys... you can throw the 3. Meninga in there too if you like

 

[Bigfella]

eadie
thompson
gibbs
krillich


ridge
lyons
toovey
serdaris
thats a tough one to go past

If you are compiling a list of all time best to compete with all time greats from other clubs, it would actually be very easy to go past any list with either "Gibbs" or "Serdaris" in it.

 

[Harold Bishop]

If you are compiling a list of all time best to compete with all time greats from other clubs, it would actually be very easy to go past any list with either "Gibbs" or "Serdaris" in it.

Disagree, Gibbs was a great player cruelled by injury. Wasn't picked on the 78' Kanagaroo tour for nothing.

Sedaris, another NSW and Australian rep. Dally M hooker of the year 94,96.
Des Hasler was also used as an interchange Hooker in 96.

 

[Non Terminator]

LOL!!!!

1. Mullins/Badge
6. Daley
7. Stuart
9. Walters

Game. Set. Match.
Thank you lines men, thank you ball boys... you can throw the 3. Meninga in there too if you like

Well played.
I will go loyal and throw in a:

1. Fairfax
6. Fittler
7. Thicknesse
9. Pearce

I know it's unpredictable to choose Thicknesse and Pearce, since none of us have seen their ability. I'm just going by folklore.

 

[Loudstrat]

LOL at the Manly lineups - two of them that don't include Fulton.

Here's the winner:

Thornett
Kenny
Sterling
Edge

The Raiders and Broncos mentioned would fight out the reserve grade spots.

And the Bears half would obviously be Thompson, not Taylor.

 

[Non Terminator]

Not bad Loudstrat...but we might have a winner here:

HUNTER MARINERS
1. Robbie Ross
6. Scott Hill
7. Brett Kimmorley
9. Robbie McCormack

:lol:

 

[innsaneink]

=1 Hodgo+
=6 Benji
=7 Prince
=9 Farah
05 magic