What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Logo Change

1 Eyed TEZZA

Coach
Messages
12,420
Yeah not a fan of the jersey, but the logo is ok. I think it needs more personality to be honest. A more animated Kangaroo. Not cartoonish, but bigger more defined.
 

Titanic

First Grade
Messages
5,954
Far too PNG ... I just can't get passed a really decent predominantly black and gold (away reversed) design reflecting WA's traditional colours.
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
73,687
a predominantly black colour is not good for a place as hot as Perth!

re logo, I prefer our modern looking one, that is classic looking but not very "appealing" to the next generation.
 

joondalup_giant

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
1,778
i think the jersey looks good, pretty simple but effective. agree with what 1 Eyed Tezza said about the logo

Yeah not a fan of the jersey, but the logo is ok. I think it needs more personality to be honest. A more animated Kangaroo. Not cartoonish, but bigger more defined.
 

Goddo

Bench
Messages
4,257
a predominantly black colour is not good for a place as hot as Perth!

re logo, I prefer our modern looking one, that is classic looking but not very "appealing" to the next generation.

The current reds logo is aweful. Sorry, but it is.

Put it next to Brisbane, St George, Manly, Parramatta, Souths et al and it looks god aweful. It is worse than the Bears bid logo, and the Chooks...

The basic elements of it are ok (sunrise from original logo, kangaroo), but the fact its cartoonie, fat, wearing a t-shirt and carrying a ball while looking like its passing stones ruins it.

I think Gazf's logo is closer to the mark, but can be improved.
 
Last edited:

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
73,687
The current reds logo is aweful. Sorry, but it is.

Put it next to Brisbane, St George, Manly, Parramatta, Souths et al and it looks god aweful. It is worse than the Bears bid logo, and the Chooks...

The basic elements of it are ok (sunrise from original logo, kangaroo), but the fact its cartoonie, fat, wearing a t-shirt and carrying a ball while looking like its passing stones ruins it.

I think Gazf's logo is closer to the mark, but can be improved.

each to their own, personally I prefer something energetic and young to something that looks like its come off a coat of arms.
 

1 Eyed TEZZA

Coach
Messages
12,420
I think a more professional logo would attract more professional sponsors and business. Its not a big deal, but it would be a more respectable image.

I think that would be a good challenge. People out there who are good with photoshop, design a Reds logo.
 

Lockyer4President!

First Grade
Messages
7,975
I think a more professional logo would attract more professional sponsors and business. Its not a big deal, but it would be a more respectable image.

I think that would be a good challenge. People out there who are good with photoshop, design a Reds logo.

It's better than 90% of the team logos in the AFL and A-League tbh. We're just so used to having high quality logos in the NRL we forget what a bad one can look like.

Adelaide_Crows_logo.png

Essendon_logo_2010.png

Geelong2008Logo.svg

2006_AFL_Port_Adelaide.png

2006_AFL_Richmond.jpg
 

Lockyer4President!

First Grade
Messages
7,975
Couple more, including another kangaroo logo so you can compare it to the Reds logo.


North_Melbourne_Football_Club_Logo.png

GoldCoastSunsLogo_%282%29.jpg

Gwsgiants1.jpg


Super 14 teams are generally pretty shocking/amateur hour aswell.

highlanders_logo.jpg
 

Nuke

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
5,718
Are you serious? THAT's a real logo?

Geez Louise. Personally, I don't mind the tip-of-the-hat to the original Western Reds logo as the WA Reds logo, however it's too manga / childish in my eyes as it is.
It's 1:30am here as I type this, so I won't have a crack at it tonight, but I enjoy making / toying with logos, so I'll maybe give it a go one day soon and see what comes of it. Just for the fun of it!

The hard part is going to come from the fact that kangaroos are quite a popular thing to have in a logo in Australia, so designing one that essentially hasn't been done before is going to prove quite challenging.
 

Nuke

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
5,718
I've had a little bit of a muck around in the past few days. In the end, I felt an update would be the best direction to take (instead of a complete overhaul). As you'll see below, what I've essentially done is change the angle that the kangaroo is heading. In the Western Reds logo and the current WA Reds logo, the kangaroo is going from left to right. In my one, I made him head left to right, but also towards you (the viewer). I don't know if this was the intention of the original designer, but to me it's saying that he's coming from the west.
I've tried to keep as much of the kangaroo's posture and other elements of the previous two logos the same. He's still carrying a footy under his right arm, and still has a clenched left fist. The tail and closest leg is still one object, seperated from the rest of the body. I prefer the eyes on the original Reds logo over the WA Reds logo, so I've simplified it again. Something a little different is the background shape: It's one of those road signs you see that have the black kangaroo silhoutetted images on it. It means to watch out for kangaroos, which I felt was appropriate! That yellow sign background also allowed a slight acknowledgement to the big golden sun in the background of the original Western Reds logo. This, I thought, would help associate people with the original logo. The style of the words 'WA' and 'REDS' I kept from the current WA Reds logo. For starters, I liked it, and secondly, I felt it'd help with the transition from the current WA Reds logo.
One noticable thing I did different was that I removed his footy jersey. I didn't feel it looked good on my little fella, so left it off. I don't feel it was important anyway.

So yeah, I hope you like it! I'll probably keep playing around when I get time and have the motivation.
WARedsalternatelogocomparison.jpg
 

docbrown

Coach
Messages
11,842
So yeah, I hope you like it! I'll probably keep playing around when I get time and have the motivation.
WARedsalternatelogocomparison.jpg

Very nice, the logo pops out at you and grabs your attention - much better than a profile image.

I'd say maybe try dotting the eye (subtle pupil) though - the solid white makes it look a little like a zombie ;-) If it's in the bottom corner, it'd give the effect that he's also look right at you (as he's coming towards you). Also, I might suggest sharpening the tail & ears to a point.

As I said, losing the jersey is definitely the way to go. Is it possible to get the yellow in the image changed to 'Old Gold'?

Old Gold for the Diamond, 'W.A.' and also trimmed around the 'REDS' (so a dual old gold/black border) to make the REDS stand apart from the kangaroo. Perhaps maybe the football as well.

All in all, it's very nicely done, congrats. :thumb
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
73,687
well done Nuke, hidden talents! Can you design us something for the Red Army?

I like it coming towards much better, more animated. Yeh the Old Gold would be good
 

BDGS

Bench
Messages
4,102
WARedsalternatelogocomparison.jpg


Get rid of the "Est 2013" i feel that not only does that look weird but it is wrong, especially if the WA Reds follow on from the record books of the previous Western and Perth Reds and you would say they would.

Also the eyes make it look like a zombie.
 

Nuke

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
5,718
The 'old gold' idea was one I toyed with, but didn't really look vibrant enough in my eyes. On a jersey, it'd look fantastic, but on the logo ... I wasn't so sure.

The 'Give Way' sign was intentional. Like I said in my spiel, it's meant to represent those road signs you see warning people that there are kangaroos around and to watch out for them (ie: other teams should watch out for the WA Red(kangaroo)s).
Kangaroo_Sign.jpg


I didn't think the WA Reds should just be a follow-on from the 1990's Western (Perth) Reds team, hence the fresh start with 2013 being their first year in the NRL competition. That was why I threw that in there (admittedly at the last minute!).

Ears weren't pointed as they moved away from pointed ears in the current WA Reds logo (see the comparisons in my post above). It also allowed me to make one in the shape of WA. Tail wasn't pointed a) because they're not in real life, and b) they've not been in the previous logos.

Here is a version of it using most of the suggestions mentioned above. Sharpening the tail and ears would be too much effort for me to do it tonight. I tried having the 'old gold' surrounding the text, but to be honest, white makes it stand out much more, hence why I've made it white.
WARedsalternatelogo.jpg
 
Last edited:
Top