What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

08 :: R5 Sun :: Knights 22 Broncos 34 @ EnergyAustralia

Round 5 Result :: Knights v Broncos


  • Total voters
    30
  • Poll closed .

Timmah

LeagueUnlimited News Editor
Staff member
Messages
100,992

nwc-main.jpg

NEWCASTLE KNIGHTS
1 Kurt Gidley
2 James McManus, 3 Wes Naiqama, 4 Adam MacDougall, 5 Cooper Vuna
6 Chris Bailey, 7 Scott Dureau
8 Daniel Tolar, 9 Danny Buderus (c), 10 Ben Cross
11 Zeb Taia, 12 Cory Paterson
13 Matt Hilder​

Int - 14 Chris Houston, 15 Jesse Royal, 16 Richie Fa’aoso, 17 Danny Wicks
Res - 18 Cameron Ciraldo, 19 Keith Lulia, 20 Akuila Uate​

bri-alt.jpg

BRISBANE BRONCOS
1 Karmichael Hunt
2 Denan Kemp, 3 Steve Michaels, 4 Justin Hodges ©, 5 Darius Boyd
6 David Stagg, 7 Peter Wallace
8 Ben Hannant, 9 Michael Ennis, 10 Nick Kenny
11 Sam Thaiday, 12 Ashton Sims
13 Tonie Carroll​

Int - 14 PJ Marsh, 15 Joel Clinton, 16 Greg Eastwood, 17 David Taylor
Res - 18 Joel Moon, 19 Shane Perry​


ref-orange.jpg

Referee
SHAYNE HAYNE
Sideline Officials: Chris James & Steve Carrall
Video Referee: Paul Simpkins​

Schedule
10:40am Gates open
10:55am NSW Cup
12:45pm Toyota Cup
3:00pm NRL​

Related Matches
Toyota Cup Knights v Broncos @ EnergyAustralia, Sun 12:45pm
NSW Cup Knights v Wolves @ EnergyAustralia, Sun 10:55am​
 

Johns Magic

Referee
Messages
21,654
Knights possibly without Mullen, Dureau and (likely to play)Buderus.

Broncos possibly without Lockyer, Marsh,parker and Hodges.
 

macavity

Referee
Messages
20,648
depends on injuries

2 of the 3 play, knights in with a shot

buderus out, we are little hope

similarly, if 3 of those 4 broncos are out we would have to fancy our chances

too many variables at this stage
 

Hutty1986

Immortal
Messages
34,034
depends on injuries

2 of the 3 play, knights in with a shot

buderus out, we are little hope

similarly, if 3 of those 4 broncos are out we would have to fancy our chances

too many variables at this stage

The Tipping nightmare continues!
 

keeney

First Grade
Messages
6,640
I selected the Knights in the polls, but the BRoncos should have our measure here. Our discipline is destroying us, I think we're in for a rough couple weeks.
 

gong_eagle

First Grade
Messages
7,655
Knights v Broncos Preview
Big League
http://nrl.com/News/Latest/tabid/10244/default.aspx?id=50482



ON paper you could dismiss this game as an uneven David v Goliath clash – but the Knights are showing signs of gelling into a genuine finals contender, their pack full of honest toilers and their backline taking the opportunities that are being presented their way.
But a victory here would more likely be a Herculean effort, as they’ll have to do it without star pivot Jarrod Mullen, who injured his leg against the Warriors last week.
Chris Bailey takes the hot seat outside Scott Dureau but the one blessing is he won’t have to line up opposite Darren Lockyer, who is missing with soreness to his reconstructed knee. (Lockyer’s replacement is the capable David Stagg.)
The Knights will be anxious to arrest their two-game losing streak (Eels – by a point – and Warriors) that followed their back-to-back wins over the Raiders and Sea Eagles (the latter by a point).
The Broncos have shot out of the gates with a hat-trick of wins (Panthers, Roosters, Cowboys) before being unsaddled by the Storm in Melbourne last week. They did have excuses though – they were missing major contributor Justin Hodges, who returns to the centres here.
The ominous sign for the Knights is that in two of the Broncos’ three previous wins over the Novocastrians, they managed to put on more than 50 points.
Watch out Knights: Forget Mark Gasnier, Justin Hodges is currently the world’s best centre. He’s proving it with consistent performances each week; his average 171 metres a game from three outings in 2008 ranks him second in the NRL. And while a host of fullbacks and other outside backs are averaging well over 100 metres in territory a game, they’re doing it largely on the back of kick-returns.
Not Hodges: he goes looking for action. He doesn’t even figure in the top 20 kick-returners. Instead, he makes the ground out of dummy-half, where he’s run 31 times (second in the NRL after missing 25 per cent of play!) Brian Smith will have spent hours this week drumming into his markers the desperate need to shut Hodges down before he takes more than three strides – or they’ll be back-pedalling all afternoon.
As Knights’ coach Brian Smith says in this week’s Big League: “Everyone knows he’s a handful – and he still does it.”
Watch out Broncos: Just as Hodges is the key for the Broncos, the Knights will rely heavily on fullback Kurt Gidley to give them excellent counter attack.
The difference is Gidley tends to make his territory (average 193 metres a game – top in the NRL) from kick-returns. But he’ll also be trailing Danny Buderus close to the ruck and on the fringes, just waiting for a half-chance.
Where it will be won: By kicking away from Gidley. If the Broncos can limit the Newcastle fullback to even just 120 metres, they’ll win this one. The key could be to keep switching the point of their attack, in an attempt to catch Gidley out of position, with wingers Cooper Vuna and James McManus then called on to clear the ball.
Both have limited territory this year (averaging 50 and 72 metres respectively) and could be easily flustered into errors.
The History: Played 30; Broncos 21, Knights 9. The Knights have a poor recent record winning just one of their past six games against the Broncos. The visitors well and truly hold bragging rights – flogging the Knights 71-6 at their most recent match-up last year (although that was at Suncorp Stadium).
Also, the Knights can’t hope for much of a home ground “advantage”, having lost three of the past four times they’ve met there.
Conclusion: A couple of great sub-plots here in the lead-up to the representative season – Danny Buderus has the chance to stamp his authority on the Blues’ hooking role ahead of the Wests Tigers’ Robbie Farah who has been named out of position at halfback in his game this week; Brisbane’s Peter Wallace needs to maintain his good momentum to stake a claim for the Blues’ no.7 spot; with Anthony Minichiello sidelined indefinitely Kurt Gidley is already elevated to no.2 choice behind incumbent Brett Stewart – a big game here against likely Maroons’ fullback Karmichael Hunt would hold him in good stead with selectors.
No doubt the home crowd will lift their team but if they do get the competition points, it won’t be by any flash margin.
Match officials: Referee – Shayne Hayne; Sideline Officials – Chris James & Steve Carrall; Video ref – Paul Simpkins.
Televised: Channel 9 – Delayed 4pm; FoxSports 2 – Delayed 6pm.
* Statistics: NRL Stats.
 

Apey

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
28,282
Thinking the Broncos will win, but we might lift at home and coming off two losses. Probably end up tipping Broncos in the end though :(
 

macavity

Referee
Messages
20,648
against any half decent defence, we dont have more than 20 points in us WITH Mullo. without him who knows.

I think the Broncos have more than 20 in them against any team bar perhaps Melbourne in Melbourne.

going to take a huge effort for us to get this one. Even if our pack dominates like it should (and doesnt get killed by shoddy reffing like it did last week) its going to be very very hard to contain their backs, particularly with doogs giving up his customary 5-10 line breaks a game.
 

Jobdog

Live Update Team
Messages
25,696
Big game. Big home crowd on a (hopefully) sunny Sunday arvo. This game will be a cracker, make no mistake.

Knights by 2.
 

Timmah

LeagueUnlimited News Editor
Staff member
Messages
100,992
Brisbane are 10-7 since 1988 at EAS. Overall from 30 games it's Brisbane 21 Newcastle 9.
 

Jobdog

Live Update Team
Messages
25,696
Late mail from the Knights camp is that Dureau will definitely play and Jarrod Mullen may be a shock late inclusion. Whether or not it is Brian Smith and his smoke and mirrors is anyones guess re: Mullen ...
 

Jobdog

Live Update Team
Messages
25,696
Late mail from the Knights camp is that Dureau will definitely play and Jarrod Mullen may be a shock late inclusion. Whether or not it is Brian Smith and his smoke and mirrors is anyones guess re: Mullen ...
 

Latest posts

Top