What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

08 :: R8 Sat :: Panthers 18 Eels 26 @ CUA

Round 8 Result :: Panthers v Eels


  • Total voters
    15
  • Poll closed .

Billythekid

First Grade
Messages
6,839
I just have to say to everyone crapping with this suggestion that Nathan Smith's try should have been benefit of the doubt - the rules clearly state that the try CANNOT be awarded benefit of the doubt in those circumstances.

Well for those of us who don't know the rules to the letter of the law would you mind providing a link to your claims?

Otherwise all you've done is say your wrong i'm right learn the rules.
 

oldmancraigy

Coach
Messages
11,952
I heard David Vaealiki was released maybe super coach will sign him up and Darren Tracey is looking for a start again..

Dude... we don't really have a leg to stand on to mock the Knights for their coach of all things.

1987-1995 no finals appearances.

Brian Smith signeds
Miss the finals twice in 10 years, make the second last game or grand final 6 times.

Not to mention that he rebuilt our club from the ground up.

Now maybe he's not a coach who can win premierships - but at least he designed a side that could win games without Johns.

No dobut Hagan gets the team ready for the big games - but let's just hope he's good enough in the regular season to get us in the position to play the big games!
 

HevyDevy

Coach
Messages
17,146
Well for those of us who don't know the rules to the letter of the law would you mind providing a link to your claims?

Otherwise all you've done is say your wrong i'm right learn the rules.

No I don't have a link, but just for the record: You're wrong, I'm right, learn the rules.
 

Pantherjim.

Referee
Messages
21,643
:lol::lol: Panthers fans....almost as bad as Raiders fans. Cummins was terrible in general and should be dropped, but it was your sides inability to go with Parra when they kicked up a gear that cost you the game, not him.

The Smith no try-Called held up on advice from the touchie, who told the ref he had been held up. Correct call...can anyone seriously say even after all those replays that he definitely scored? I doubt it. Benefit of the doubt be damned, the touchie had a better view than the ref and said it was held up, and the ref made the call accordingly.

The 20m restart-He caught the ball in goal, what the f**k do you want the ref to do, ignore the rules when it suits you? LOL. Perhaps the rule itself needs to be looked at....but there was nothing Cummins could have done.

Finch was tackled, eh? They must have changed the definition of a completed tackle to "as soon as the defence grabs him" when I wasn't looking.

Suck it up...you lost. That's what happens when you have terrible halves and a useless backline, and miss tackles against a side that can score points from anywhere.

Learn the rules of the game idiot, and while your about it, make an appointment to see an optometrist....
 

Y2Eel

First Grade
Messages
8,176
Dude... we don't really have a leg to stand on to mock the Knights for their coach of all things.

1987-1995 no finals appearances.

Brian Smith signeds
Miss the finals twice in 10 years, make the second last game or grand final 6 times.

Not to mention that he rebuilt our club from the ground up.

Now maybe he's not a coach who can win premierships - but at least he designed a side that could win games without Johns.

No dobut Hagan gets the team ready for the big games - but let's just hope he's good enough in the regular season to get us in the position to play the big games!


It was a piss take note by my last post Hagen for 1 more year !!

Brain did wonders for the eels too bad we couldnt have handed the team to a better coach...
 

Latest posts

Top