09 :: Origin 3 :: QLD 16 NSW 28 @ Suncorp :: Wed 15 Jul

[innsaneink]

he is a Manly Junior

Originally a Dogs or Wests junior

 

[Twizzle]

because it is an Origin game I suppose

yep

 

[Timmah]

Voss clearly doesn't know the rules, what a f**king disgrace he is to commentary, how could you NOT know the rules?

An act IN the scoring play is resultant in a PENALTY TRY. Penalty tries are where the kick is moved to right in front.

An act AFTER the scoring play is resultant in a POSSIBLE EIGHT POINT TRY. The try itself is awarded, the regular conversion takes place, plus a penalty goal attempt afterwards in front. QLD failed to understand the concept of "Possible eight point try" because "possible" means if he missed one of the kicks it's still only 6 points :lol:

Vossy, f**k up and read a rule book.

 

[Jono078]

I love Watmough.

 

[Garts]

Not a send off imo for Thurston, correct decision.

 

[Chook Norris]

for the first time in a while, i can say i was happy with the NSW intensity in the first half

c'mon.. we can win this..

oh and yer, a big F you to Wolfman for the drop ball

 

[Frank_Grimes]

One would think a punch to the head from behind would be a send off too........ but it wasn't.

 

[Flapper]

That was thurstons best kick all night it hit right where he aimed, pity for the cowboys that he'll be out for 4 weeks now after a dead rubber.

At least 1 week is all I need :lol:

 

[Kilkenny]

As an impartial spectator the 8 point try ruling was clearly the correct decision.

The ruling to aware the try in the first instance was also correct and I dont care who wins.

 

[Frank_Grimes]

Voss clearly doesn't know the rules, what a f**king disgrace he is to commentary, how could you NOT know the rules?

An act IN the scoring play is resultant in a PENALTY TRY. Penalty tries are where the kick is moved to right in front.

An act AFTER the scoring play is resultant in a POSSIBLE EIGHT POINT TRY. The try itself is awarded, the regular conversion takes place, plus a penalty goal attempt afterwards in front. QLD failed to understand the concept of "Possible eight point try" because "possible" means if he missed one of the kicks it's still only 6 points :lol:

Vossy, f**k up and read a rule book.

All irrelevant given the fact that Williams DROPPED THE BALL.

 

[Downie]

Watmough, and to a lesser extent Creagh and Hayne, have been running the show for NSW tonight.

And if NSW lose I guess Williams will be made the scapegoat again for that one error =/
Even though half the team has also dropped it so far.

 

[Pete Cash]

Is Tom Learoyd Lahrs playing prop right now ??

I am happy with him so far, but I am biased because of my man-crush on him.

 

[Tonearm Terrorwrist]

Hahaha Ray Warren is such a senile old man, it's truely time to go. When commenting on the Cam Smith no try Sterlo points out that a NSW player knocks the ball out and proceded to say "If it came off his knee and bounced then it's play on and a fair try" then Ray Warren says "If it comes off his leg before touching the ground that makes it a try aswell" LOL that's EXACTLY what Sterlo just said.

 

[kia ora storm]

As an impartial spectator the 8 point try ruling was clearly the correct decision.

The ruling to aware the try in the first instance was also correct and I dont care who wins.

You don't care who wins...but would like Qld to lose.;-)

 

[Jono078]

If Johnson's was a try so was Wolfmans tbh.

 

[hunters]

I couldn't see an 8 point try there, but I'll take the points

honestly that was soft, this is origin

Soft! He kicked a bloke in the head while he was laying on the ground.

There are ways to be tough without that sort of stuff.

 

[Frank_Grimes]

Slater has been absolutely useless tonight.

 

[Garts]

All irrelevant given the fact that Williams DROPPED THE BALL.

I agree that should not be a try but it is pretty much within the rules, he lost control but got his hand back on it before he grounded it or at the same time. Based on the rules it is a try.

 

[Knights_Premiers]

One would think a punch to the head from behind would be a send off too........ but it wasn't.

You can't defend a kick to the head though. Barrett on Inglis was quite possibly accidental. QLD players are dirty, grubby players, face it and live with it.

 

[Frank_Grimes]

If Johnson's was a try so was Wolfmans tbh.

Williams dropped the ball from his hands. You can knock on from your hands - not your torso. It's very simple and it happened to Brisbane earlier this year.