What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

'10 | QF1 - 4 v 5 | Fri | Titans 28-16 Warriors | Skilled (NZW elim)

Qualifying Final Result: Titans v Warriors


  • Total voters
    32
  • Poll closed .
Messages
17,822
Maloney's going good mate. Happy with him. Seymour is organising well for the most part I feel as well. I feel this is why there was such interest in Feleti Mateo, someone who can create opportunities through ball skill. A lot of our tries comes off one off aggression by a guy like Vatuvei steam rolling his opponent, or a well placed kick (bomb or grubber). You are quite right, if there was a great instinctive half in say a Prince or a Thurston then it'd be a tough night at the office for our opponents. Such is life. We have a great talent in the NYC by the name of Shaun Johnson, who will be groomed next year in the Vulcans for a long term shot at halfback.

For the record, the turning point for me was the analus horribilis piece of refereeing by Gavin 'I'll gag on it if you want Johnny C' Badger when he penalised Rapira for being offside at marker, when he was clearly on side. A turnover just on halfway compared to defending from 25-30m out with a fresh set, had a massive impact on the flow of the game in terms of whom had the ball for the next 10-15 minutes. I would say Gavin made a guess, because there's no way he could have clearly observed that player and thought he was offside. Nevertheless, such is life, and this is football, and what happened beyond that (poor goal line D and errors in our own half) are sins we have largely not been committing these past 2 months. I don't really want to get into the habit of criticising Badger, I have a lot of respect for the bloke for one reason... most weekends he's the only referee still wearing the Sonny Fai band. Respect for that.

We were overawed by the occasion I suspect. I look at a guy like Ben Matulino... he barely seemed to make errors throughout the season, last night it looked like he had jelly for hands. Defensively he barely seems to miss, and usually in actual fact he gets dominant tackles. He got blitzed by Zillman. When a back runs in Matulino's channel generally they should be warned they're in a for a world of hurt, but he was off his game. I can't recall us dropping any kick returns this year. Last night we put down two. Manu Vatuvei had a great game going forward, but he panicked on a couple of offloads turning over possession twice in our half when his run had given us some momentum for that set. Ukuma Ta'ai's footwork defensively is usually very good, last night he did a lot of jersey grabbing as he lunged out of the line looking to overplay his hand to make an impact. It wasn't a matter of no effort, it was just I feel at times they were overawed and trying to overplay their way out of it. It'll be a very good learning curve for those players. IMO, if we get another chance, we'll be a lot better for the run. The mistakes we were making are not familiar mistakes for us in 2010.

If this is the end for us this year, I'm very proud of what we achieved. We were one of the favourites for wooden spoon. We had an enormous list of injuries (key ones at that). Yet here we are, with somewhat of a chance to get into week 2 of the finals. We are club champions, and we do have a good system developing good players for a good future.

Most of all, well played Gold Coast. Prince was too accurate. Friend was troublesome out of dummy half. Rogers is such a deceptive talent even at this stage of his career. And Zillman has always been an epic talent, hopefully he is now going to consistently deliver on his potential. They are well coached by a coach who is underrated. Good luck to Gold Coast for the remainder of the finals.

Johnson will be good for the Warriors...no doubt.

I don't think the Warriors played badly last night, I think you got it right as they just seemed to be flat in patches and did not step up to the intensity that they have shown they can do in past finals such as when they beat Storm in Melbourne.

Vatuvei was good but did not need to throw the miracle passes in a couple of instances.

I think they needed the likes of Steve Price to settle them down and give them composure IMO.

I would like to see them get another crack next week as I think you would see a different side to them next week.
 

Meth

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
35,783
Our big problem last night was that we were at least 1 genuine prop short- we clearly lost our composure and go-forward when Rapira and Packer left the field and didn't really regain it until it was too late.

Lillyman played well; Matulino was CRAP. Perhaps we would have been better to play Royal over Lousi.

We really missed Mara.

We capitulated mentally and the Titans were better prepared for finals football.

Hopefully we will have another chance next week and our young guys will be better for the experience.
 

KeepingTheFaith

Referee
Messages
25,235
They do have the class to rise that extra level but they have consistently struggled since Jones retired to get a playmaker that can break a game open.

Moloney is getting there and has good potential but IMO until they can get a 5/8 in the mould of Prince or Thurston then it is not gonna happen for them.

Throw an extra couple of seasons experience onto the current squad and it's a different story, but they were never going to make an impact on the finals.

Maloney is very good and will get better, but they don't have players in the class of Benji, Farah, Carney, Lockyer, Slater etc.

Some very classy juniors coming through though.
 
Top