What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

'12 | R24 | Fri | Bulldogs 23-22* Tigers | ANZ

Round 24 result: Bulldogs v Tigers

  • Draw after Golden Point

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    23
  • Poll closed .

Mr Saab

Referee
Messages
27,762
What about when a scrum went againt the feed and Maxwell blew the whistle and made them re feed it. The ball richoted off a tigers leg and came back to the Dogs....should have been fair play, but that merkin Maxwell thought otherwise.
Bill Harrigan needs to be sacked
 

IFR33K

Coach
Messages
17,043
What about when a scrum went againt the feed and Maxwell blew the whistle and made them re feed it. The ball richoted off a tigers leg and came back to the Dogs....should have been fair play, but that merkin Maxwell thought otherwise.
Bill Harrigan needs to be sacked

Agreed. I thought play on as well, yet I reckon all wests fans will claim the right call was made.
 

851

Bench
Messages
3,141
Moreso over your constant bagging of the Tigers. I've seen plenty of neutral fans who don't follow either team say the Tigers were ripped off aswell, not one eyeing anything. Shouldn't you be pissed the refs are continually getting calls wrong despite all the technology?

and lol @ you still saying Canberra got dudded in 2010. First of all it's nearly 2 years ago, 2nd of all Tigers were the much superior team for 90% of the game, and last of all Jarod Choker had a chance to take it into golden point, but he..choked
Thanks mate summed it up nicely,what about the diabolical reffing in favour of Canberra last week,no mention,and the diabolical video ref decision to award the Storm a try last night,but no the refs favour the Tigers and only the Tigers.
Reynolds in front of Keating for the second try,Farah no try and the sheppard,2 tries to the Dogs that shouldn't have been awarded,and 1 try to the Tigers that should have been awarded.
I will deadset wet myself if Easts beat you on a forward pass or any dodgy men in pink call,because that my friend will be karma.
Sorry to the genuine Raider fans as their are quite a few on here,but he just leaves himself open.
 

Clifferd

Coach
Messages
10,805
So now not only did we lose that crucial game by 1 point, now Farah has a confirmed fractured hand.


For f**k sake. We might be officially done.
 

dogslife

Coach
Messages
18,992
I reckon instead of being the hero, Robbie could have easily passed to Marshall who probably would have slotted a couple of easy field goals
 

innsaneink

Referee
Messages
29,384
I reckon instead of being the hero, Robbie could have easily passed to Marshall who probably would have slotted a couple of easy field goals

Not about trying to be a hero you loser, hes potted plenty of FGs from DH before.

Last night proved two things.

*Sheens is correct, Bulldogs have plenty of cracks in their armour, theyre definitely beatable.

*We can mix it with the best should we get there in Sept
 

innsaneink

Referee
Messages
29,384
What about when a scrum went againt the feed and Maxwell blew the whistle and made them re feed it. The ball richoted off a tigers leg and came back to the Dogs....should have been fair play, but that merkin Maxwell thought otherwise.
Bill Harrigan needs to be sacked
Yep...I thought we got lucky there....in these instances when they go your teams way you generally forget them pretty quick, same for all teams
 

dogslife

Coach
Messages
18,992
Bet you Marshall has a better success rate standing at first receiver. Robbie was all class shirking his media responsibilities too
 

Clifferd

Coach
Messages
10,805
Bet you Marshall has a better success rate standing at first receiver. Robbie was all class shirking his media responsibilities too

I don't blame him really. He's not the first captain to do it either.

Also you gotta remember he broke his hand so that could of been a reason but probably not.
 

jonno_knights

Juniors
Messages
2,147
Well probably for the best the Tigers lost. With Farah likely done for the season, they dont have much chance in September missing numerous key positional players, as its highly unlikely Benji can carry them for 4 consecutive games.

Hopefully the Knights can seize the opportunity. Will probably need 2/3 while maintaining a superior F/A to the Tigs, as I reckon the Tigers will split their two games. Should be enough to hold off any challenge from the Raiders/Titans too.
 

ironhorse

Juniors
Messages
1,062
What about when a scrum went againt the feed and Maxwell blew the whistle and made them re feed it. The ball richoted off a tigers leg and came back to the Dogs....should have been fair play, but that merkin Maxwell thought otherwise.
Bill Harrigan needs to be sacked

Yes !!! X 4 !! Forgot about that ...it was play on,, the ball had been feed correctly through the tunnel and out . Wildly bouncing off a Tiger 2nd rowers legs ..that was bulldogs ball and play on.
 

Packy

Bench
Messages
4,243
The NRL CHANNEL 9 Tigers arent used to not getting everything their way. I understand their shock
 

ouwet

Bench
Messages
3,992
Reynolds was off-side for his try from the Keating kick
Classic obstruction for the Jonathan Wright try
I will bet my house upon replay that Farah gets the ball down and there is sufficient evidence to award Benefit of the Doubt at the VERY least!.

Tigers are potentially up by 18 and the Barba try arguably doesn't eventuate also.

Tigers win for your life!!!.


Look at the replay, Reynolds was onside (In line is fine)... Farah's try, I'm sorry but HOW CAN A VIDEO REF give BOD when he cannot see the ball touch the ground (AND YOU CANNOT SEE IT), can he give it because Robbie Farah's a good bloke and wouldn't lie? PLEASE, the Video ref made the right call and went back to the ref.

The obstruction was a shocker... But IF it wasn't scored, the remaining 4 minutes would've been different, Tiger's were still down by 2 and would've been working it out from there own end. Tiger's won the penalty count 7-2 FFS.

The whole weekend I've heard Tiger's supporters whinging on radio about golden point and the Video Ref... I didn't hear them whinge when they won golden point in Round 1 against Cronulla, OR I didn't hear them whinge when the Sharks got robbed in Rd 1 also.
 

Latest posts

Top