1st Chappell/Hadlee Trophy Match AUS v NZ @ WACA

[Spike]

tbh Broom deserved to be out

 

[Timmah]

Australia cheating as usual!!!

Oh f*ck off. Cheating? :lol: You're a goose.

 

[Bazal]

Am I correct in thinking a situation like that will be avoided in South Africa as they're implementing a trial of the three challenges rule?

If it was challenged, yes. If it's not challenged then it makes no difference...Broom looked happy enough to go with the umpire's call tbh, as wrong as it was

 

[El Diablo]

Ah ha! There is evidence of what just happened with that dismissal. Sure slow replays can make ya doubt but that ball just barely skipped the bails and it was the keepr's gloves that knocked the bails off!

Australia cheating as usual!!!

onya Hads

 

[Dragon]

Would've been nice to see Broom sweep more...could've really cleaned up

:alcho:

 

[shiznit]

Not now that he's in the sheds no...

ohhh okay...

well people were debating the worst way to get out...

i think weve found a winner...

 

[Timmah]

It's not just the umpires the players have to know and not go ahead and think they are above the law which Australia do. Again

Yeah because the other ten players on the field had laser vision meaning they knew what happened :crazy:

To the naked eye he was bowled.

 

[Meth]

Its not Aussie cheating- it's incompetent officiating

 

[Bazal]

It's not just the umpires the players have to know and not go ahead and think they are above the law which Australia do. Again

:lol::lol::lol:
STFU. Haddin had no way of knowing he'd taken the bails. That part of the gloves is just material, he can't feel it.

 

[Meth]

tbh Broom deserved to be out

How do you figure?

 

[Bazal]

ohhh okay...

well people were debating the worst way to get out...

i think weve found a winner...

IIRC he can be called back while he's on the playing surface...or before the next ball is bowled. Not 100% sure which, but I wish the third umpire could intervene. He might be a dirty kiwi p) but that was incredibly rough

 

[Meth]

To the naked eye he was bowled.

In saying that, Broom seemed to think something was awry

 

[Spike]

How do you figure?

He's a kiwi

 

[shiznit]

i think i would put it in a similar vain to someone being caught when the bowler steps over the mark...

technically its not out as it should be a no ball... but because the umpire didn't call it you have to take it on the chin...

if memory serves me right Warne missed out on a century because of a front foot no ball being missed...

 

[KeepingTheFaith]

What SHOULD have happened was once Taylor and Broom started feeling comfortable and getting on top Vettori should've called the power play and attempted to deliver a knockout blow. Clark wouldn't of even been bowling.

South Africa leave it to the last few overs, that's fine because they've usually still got decent batters or Morkel at the crease. There's no point in NZ and Australia trying to copy them when they don't have the same players.

Besides, I thought powerplays were there to make the 15-40 over mark more exciting. So much for that theory.

 

[Meth]

He's a kiwi

clever :roll:

 

[Cumberland Throw]

Would've been nice to see Broom sweep more...could've really cleaned up

:alcho:

The thought of that has me bristling with excitement

 

[eddiesmith]

:lol: Some great posting here

Of course no blame can be placed on Haddin, the umpire is supposed to be able to tell that the keeper knocked over the stumps rather than the ball when Haddin apparently didnt even see it :lol:

 

[Timmah]

Maybe, but he played an ordinary shot and was summarily dismissed.

 

[Meth]

Maybe, but he played an ordinary shot and was summarily dismissed.

So he was bowled cleanly? Or not?