What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

2008 PREMIERS Manly Warringah 40 def Storm 0 @ ANZ, Sun 5 Oct

2008 PREMIERS - Melbourne or Manly?


  • Total voters
    112
  • Poll closed .

Eagle_Rocker

Juniors
Messages
546
I would love nothing more then to see Beaver go out a winner, it would also be great to break our 12 year premiership drought. Melbourne's defence is incredible though, so we'll have to be at our best. Please no repeat of last year performance!!!
 

Cletus

First Grade
Messages
7,171
it should be a great game. I think Manly are a lot more focused this year compared to last year, they walked into an ambush last year. Plus form wise I'd give it to Manly on last tonights game that was an outstanding performance and probably one of Manlys best of the season. I can't wait for it!

The odds are out, Manly $1.80 Melbourne $2 with the TAB.
 
Messages
3,070
Was that supposed to intimidate or upset me in some way :?

Piss off internet hero.

Pretty much everything I said was accurate, just because you don't like it ...

No :lol: Not at all.

Your full of sh!t still.

What youve said isnt accuate. What youve said is bile + hopeful hatred.

In any case....hope Petro stays with your mob for your sake.
 

Garts

Bench
Messages
4,360
LOL at people who think Manly will win easily.

Melbourne with their origin players haven't lost by more than 4 points all season. They have the wood over Manly from last season's 34-8 shellacking in the grand final and have beaten them twice this season, the psychological edge in still in their favour.

Expect a similar game to the Manly-Melbourne game at Brookvale and a similar scoreline. Manly should enjoy some good periods of pressure and it will come down to whether Orford, finally produces in a big game which is close.

Storm by 6

A few differences now. Storm do not have Smith or Hoffman, Manly now have Lyon back who is playing damn well and taking pressure of Orford. Having him in the side makes a massive difference.
 

Evenflow

Bench
Messages
3,139
A few differences now. Storm do not have Smith or Hoffman, Manly now have Lyon back who is playing damn well and taking pressure of Orford. Having him in the side makes a massive difference.

You make some valid points there but on the other side that game was played at Brookevale, a place Storm hadn't won in 10 years. Plus Manly have to get over the psychological hurdle of only having been beaten by Melbourne 4 out of their last 5 meetings including the GF last year.

Manly might take more confidence into the game having Smith and Hoffman out but then they might run the risk of getting a bit complacent by that not to mention the anticipated press articles all week writing the Storm off. It's easy to say Manly won't fall for that as they're professionals etc but it happen to the best sides and i think even Melbourne have been guilty of it in the past.

I think it's going to be one hell of a game and i think it'll go either way by less than a converted try. But for those that say Manly will smash Melbourne i think is a bit silly. Melbourne might appear to be down and out but i get the feeling they thrive on the us versus them mentality and if the media keep up with the sort of articles they've been writing as i expect they will thay will only advantage the Storm and give them more fuel and hunger to go back to back.

Anyway, best of luck to both teams and their supporters and may the best team win. The best two teams are there.
 

Garts

Bench
Messages
4,360
You make some valid points there but on the other side that game was played at Brookevale, a place Storm hadn't won in 10 years. Plus Manly have to get over the psychological hurdle of only having been beaten by Melbourne 4 out of their last 5 meetings including the GF last year.

Manly might take more confidence into the game having Smith and Hoffman out but then they might run the risk of getting a bit complacent by that not to mention the anticipated press articles all week writing the Storm off. It's easy to say Manly won't fall for that as they're professionals etc but it happen to the best sides and i think even Melbourne have been guilty of it in the past.

I think it's going to be one hell of a game and i think it'll go either way by less than a converted try. But for those that say Manly will smash Melbourne i think is a bit silly. Melbourne might appear to be down and out but i get the feeling they thrive on the us versus them mentality and if the media keep up with the sort of articles they've been writing as i expect they will thay will only advantage the Storm and give them more fuel and hunger to go back to back.

Anyway, best of luck to both teams and their supporters and may the best team win. The best two teams are there.

All good points. I do not think Manly will smash Melbourne at all, they have enough strike power to beat us, no doubt about it. The people writing them off ar probably the same ones that wrote them off against Brisbane and the Sharks. I picked them in both those games. However in the GF I will back Manly. More experience this year, driven by the pain of last years loss and Orford has a partner with Lyon playing brilliant footy at the moment, at Brookie this year he was our only option and the Storm pressured him as they knew the ball was going his way. And when I tip Manly I do not do so with any great confidence.
 
Messages
17,822
All good points. I do not think Manly will smash Melbourne at all, they have enough strike power to beat us, no doubt about it. The people writing them off ar probably the same ones that wrote them off against Brisbane and the Sharks. I picked them in both those games. However in the GF I will back Manly. More experience this year, driven by the pain of last years loss and Orford has a partner with Lyon playing brilliant footy at the moment, at Brookie this year he was our only option and the Storm pressured him as they knew the ball was going his way. And when I tip Manly I do not do so with any great confidence.

Good post mate..good points made.

Manly looked strong last night; particularly the backline.

Stewart played brilliantly and Orford's passing game was exceptional.

Storm's best option will be play it tight in the forwards and look to Cronk for a long kicking game into the corners.
 

Garts

Bench
Messages
4,360
Hopefully we can nullify Folau and Inglis like we did last time. If we can do that we should have the composure to force repeats sets when we get the chance, unlike like last time.
 

Timmah

LeagueUnlimited News Editor
Staff member
Messages
101,003
If Cronk plays the same game he did on Friday, he'll sh*t all over Orford IMO. Orford's been great but Cronk was simply on fire.
 

Garts

Bench
Messages
4,360
If Orford plays as well as he has been playing and Cronk plays like he did on Friday he will be better but definately will not sh!t all over him. That is going to the extreme.
 

Timmah

LeagueUnlimited News Editor
Staff member
Messages
101,003
I'm a man of extremes, what can I say? :crazy:

I'll do up some "I'm on the bandwagon" banners tonight. I'll jump on Melbourne's... can't bring myself to cheer for Manly.
 

Garts

Bench
Messages
4,360
I suspected as much, It is not hard to tell how much you dislike Manly from your posts.
 

Garts

Bench
Messages
4,360
No need to call the police for that Timmah, that would be stupid. Although I guess you are :)
 
Top