I have to tip the winner of the Toyota cup by mid february for a tipping competition
I'd prefer a safety first approach because you score 10 points for the premier, 6 for 2nd and 3 for both knocked out the week before the gf
anybody want to provide some decent analysis and throw club allegiance out the window ?
or does anybody know of a decent season appraisal by a respected journo that maybe has been printed
I don't watch much Toyota cup at all, but I take it that a side might be young one year ... ie all 18yo's and not many of them go up to first grade due to a stable NRL side ... and say they go fairly well ... then the following year with basically the same side and all being almost max age they go nuts and do really well ... is that a fair statement ?
It would appear that Canberra got somewhat plundered after winning the comp in 2008 and then only went so-so in 2009 ... maybe a rebuilding year by Toyota cup standards
I'm a broncos supporter, and we seem to be strongish each year, without winning the comp ... i would imagine our recruiting is comprehensive and wide reaching
any obvious top 8 sides from last year fit into that sort of category ? any guidance on this would be appreciated
Oink !
Every year is different and there will be a team that nobody really expected to do well that will be in the top 4. For this year's competition, I'd have the Wests Tigers, Melbourne Storm, Sydney Roosters and South Sydney Rabbitohs as my top 4.
The Tigers have some very good players in key positions with the likes of Jake Mullaney, Robert Lui, Liam Ayoub, Patrick Politoni and Matt Hyland most likely to fill in at 1,6,7,9 and 13 respectively. Add the likes of Aaron Woods, Junior Roqica, Faleula Finau, Ben Murdoch, Daniel Ahsin and Sama Sauvao and they are definitely a force to be reckoned with.
They should line-up like this:
1. Jake MULLANEY
2. Faleula FINAU
3. Joel WISBEY
4. Junior ROQICA
5. Sama SAUVAO
6. Robert LUI
7. Liam AYOUB
8. Neil BEGOVICH
9. Patrick POLITONI
10. Aaron WOODS
11. Leivaha PULU
12. Ben MURDOCH
13. Matt HYLAND (C)
14. Jay FLORIMO
15. Daniel AHSIN
16. Brendan ADAMS
17. Matthew GROAT
The Storm will want to repeat last season's thriller year and have got some class players in their line-up that will serve them very well. Dane Chisholm, Slade Griffin, Theodore Stuart, Justin O'Neill, James Woolford, Matt Duffie and Pita Maile will look to gain an edge on their opponents and will be more than capable of doing that. Add in young players Ben Hampton, Jarome Wilson and Maipele Morseau and they will be very, very good.
They should line-up like this:
1. Joshua JEROME
2. Justin O'NEILL
3. Pita MAILE
4. Slade GRIFFIN
5. Matt DUFFIE
6. Dane CHISHOLM (C)
7. Jake HAWKINS
8. Jordan McLEAN
9. James WOOLFORD
10. James BARKER
11. Robert ROCHOW
12. Theodore STUART
13. Blake LEARY
14. Lucas GRECH
15. Sepeti AFU
16. Sam MARTIN
17. Kenny BROMWICH
The Roosters will be looking to make the finals for the first time in the NYC and have the team to do it. They've got players such as Joseph Leilua, Boyd Cordner, Cheyse Blair, Jacob Miller, Ryan Williamson, Hughie Stanley, Isaac Maliota, Brad Murray, JP Du Plessis and Fine Moeakiola currently eligible for NYC but training with first grade. Plenty of speed out wide and the forwards will be very mobile. Add in players such as Ethan Lowe, Jerome Leolahi and Olireti Samuelu and they should do well.
They should line-up like this:
1. Hughie STANLEY
2. Fine MOEAKIOLA
3. Ryan WILLIAMSON
4. JP DU PLESSIS
5. Cheyse BLAIR
6. Matthew HANDS (C)
7. Brad MURRAY
8. Isaac MALIOTA
9. Olireti SAMUELU
10. Lepuha PASEKA
11. Boyd CORDNER
12. Joseph LEILUA
13. Jerome LEOLAHI
14. Tom PELO
15. Sam BRUNTON
16. Ethan LOWE
17. John LEIATAUA
Souths probably have th best backline in the NYC. There is plenty to like about them as they have a great side with the likes of Dylan Farrell, Malcolm Webster, Adam Reynolds, Kane Morgan, Junior Vai Vai, Matthew Mundine and Jacob Nansen. Jack Lee-Hang will come up after SG Ball. He is one to watch for the future. Players such as Josh Starling, Blake Judd and Jack Tulemau will get the job done for them.
They should line-up like this:
1. Malcolm WEBSTER
2. Josh MANSOUR
3. Junior VAI VAI
4. Dylan FARRELL
5. Kane MORGAN
6. Matthew MUNDINE
7. Adam REYNOLDS (C)
8. Jacob NANSEN
9. Nathan PEATS
10. Jake SHEARER
11. Hayden O'DONNELL
12. Blake JUDD
13. Kennedy PETTYBOURNE
14. Daryl BRENNAN
15. Manasseh WATENE
16. Jack TULEMAU
17. Josh STARLING
The next bunch I think will be North QLD Cowboys, Newcastle Knights, Canberra Raiders and St George Illawarra Dragons.
Bottom teams IMO will be Manly Sea Eagles and Penrith Panthers.