Yes sorry all, largely my fault ... I was hosting a dinner for a visiting university, posted early myself and had passed the baton to Misanthrope as I ran out the door. I hadn't heard from TTL up until then so I had given instructions for Chris to call bgdc who was on standby if it got too close. I suppose 6 articles should guarantee a win just kidding. We certainly all know the rules and will happily accept whatever decision the ref makes. Apologies again for the controversy.