2017 Elim Final, Sat - Sea Eagles 10-22 Panthers @ Allianz

[Canard]

The issue is the ref needs a "I have no f**king idea option"

They did for 15 years and everyone complained about it. There was certainly no "less" controversy then there is now.

When it was inconclusive it went with Refs Call anyway.

 

[Canard]

Loss in a big game and Manly coach blaming referees afterward. What a shock.

Seems Manly haven't legitimately lost a game in a decade.

 

[umina panther]

They did for 15 years and everyone complained about it. There was certainly no "less" controversy then there is now.

When it was inconclusive it went with Refs Call anyway.

Try, No try, I don't know

its very simple stuff

 

[Nealo 12]

Was a try, ball never touched his hand... Let's all move on.

 

[veggiepatch1959]

f**k off punk, 82 was a time to be alive.

Manly's team were full of stars but still got arse raped by the mighty Eels.

Arko still has Cold sweats over the brilliance of Kenny and Sterlo arse raping Mongly.

Wind back to the 1976 GF if you want to live in the past.

Neville Glover - MOTM for Manly that day.

 

[betcats]

Peach scoring that try is karma for Dylan Walker being a dick.

 

[slamminsam246]

Conclusive.

 

[Spot On]

A couple of Uate specials cost Manly in the end. You roll the dice with a bloke like that and it can hurt you at the very worst moments.

 

[Danish]

Ridiculous decision. You'd think they would have cleared that dumbass rule up after the Hodgson try in 2006 origin.

If that happens while peachey is running into a ball in his own half, the refs call it a knock on 100% of the time, and not a single panthers player would have raised a syllable of complaint. They'd have patted peachey on the head and tell him to watch the ball into the hands next time.

You should not be allowed to propell the ball forward and gain advantage, unless it is off your foot. Everything else - hands, arms, chest, head, thighs, whatever - should be a knock on.

Peachey shouldn't be rewarded for being such a f**king spastic that he couldnt get his hands on a ball he was attempting to catch

 

[mave]

Ridiculous decision. You'd think they would have cleared that dumbass rule up after the Hodgson try in 2006 origin.

If that happens while peachey is running into a ball in his own half, the refs call it a knock on 100% of the time, and not a single panthers player would have raised a syllable of complaint. They'd have patted peachey on the head and tell him to watch the ball into the hands next time.

You should not be allowed to propell the ball forward and gain advantage, unless it is off your foot. Everything else - hands, arms, chest, head, thighs, whatever - should be a knock on.

Peachey shouldn't be rewarded for being such a f**king spastic that he couldnt get his hands on a ball he was attempting to catch

Agreed re the refs calling it a knock on if it happened anywhere else on the field.

And yet again that is where the main issue is...the complete lack of consistency is what fustrates fans.

 

[mave]

Conclusive.

If it was that close, I wonder how the bunker found conclusive evidence to overturn the on field call.

Baffling stuff.

 

[Card Shark]

Conclusive.

They can produce a (world record) line in the swimming that moves along the pool but stays parallel to the blocks.

Why didn't the 2 million dollar bunker have this installed?

Surely offside is 1 of the most likely things checked...a means of making it more black & white would've been a given!

 

[Desert Qlder]

Can we whine like btches for the next 5 years?

You've started strongly.

 

[Jason Maher]

Ridiculous decision. You'd think they would have cleared that dumbass rule up after the Hodgson try in 2006 origin.

If that happens while peachey is running into a ball in his own half, the refs call it a knock on 100% of the time, and not a single panthers player would have raised a syllable of complaint. They'd have patted peachey on the head and tell him to watch the ball into the hands next time.

You should not be allowed to propell the ball forward and gain advantage, unless it is off your foot. Everything else - hands, arms, chest, head, thighs, whatever - should be a knock on.

Peachey shouldn't be rewarded for being such a f**king spastic that he couldnt get his hands on a ball he was attempting to catch

Perhaps, but that is not what the rules of the game say.

 

[the seagull]

And it's the Bunkers fault that Walker was in front of the kicker and Uate droppped the ball under the post denying Manly two tries. Maybe the bunker could explain to Barret the importance of staying behind the Kicker and actually not dropping the ball over the line.

Or yeah that's right Barret thinks you can drop the ball over the line going back to comments he made after Uate drop ball try against the knights.. Karma's a b*tch.

Typical Barret blame everyone else but your coaching ability..

 

[Danny-Boy]

And it's the Bunkers fault that Walker was in front of the kicker and Uate droppped the ball under the post denying Manly two tries. Maybe the bunker could explain to Barret the importance of staying behind the Kicker and actually not dropping the ball over the line.

Or yeah that's right Barret thinks you can drop the ball over the line going back to comments he made after Uate drop ball try against the knights.. Karma's a b*tch.

Typical Barret blame everyone else but your coaching ability..

Walker was behind the kicker you f**king idiot. Check the pic above.

 

[butchmcdick]

Walker was behind the kicker you f**king idiot. Check the pic above.

I wonder how much it would cost to get a straight line added to the screen for the bunker to rule on offside ?

Nah that'd never work

 

[TheFrog]

he seems good defensively but that's about all he offers

Inspiration. Leadership. All those things that Robbie Farah didn't.

 

[Clifferd]

Inspiration. Leadership. All those things that Robbie Farah didn't.

Not sure if that's a personal jab at my club haha, just giving my opinion. Farah is one of those "1 year too long" players

 

[umina panther]

Walker was behind the kicker you f**king idiot. Check the pic above.

Nah he wasn't aye